The Eden Institute Biblical Herbalism Education

Find the right homeschool curriculum

Every pick in this guide passed the same checks, and nobody can pay to be on it or to move up. Browse all of it free.

114 curricula, hand-picked and checked: Christian, or secular that doesn't work against your faith. Filter by grade, subject, prep time and budget, read what other moms say, and try a free sample before you spend a dollar. How we choose

114 curricula

Some of these links pay Eden a commission if you buy. That never changes which curricula show up or the order they're in.

Abeka

Abeka (Pensacola Christian College)

Eden earns a commission

Grades K-12 · Bible, Language arts, Reading / phonics, Writing, Math, Science, History / social studies, Health / PE, Art, Music · Traditional / textbook · About $1276 (per child per year) · Christian (explicit)

What this price covers: Grade 3: Child Kit $528.95 plus Complete Parent Kit $747.30; Bible is sold separately. The pages flag a newer edition, so the current price may differ.

Try it free: Free sample video lessons for every grade and subject; no free trial found on Abeka's own pages

What moms say

Pros

  • Phonics and early reading are widely praised and get kids reading early.
  • Thorough math and grammar with lots of review built in.
  • Everything is scheduled for you, which suits moms who want a clear school plan.

Cons

  • Heavy workload with a lot of busywork, so days run long.
  • Feels like classroom school at home and is hard to adapt to one child.
  • Costly, especially with several kids or the video academy.
  • Some moms find history and science weaker, and customer service draws complaints.

From independent reviews: TheHomeSchoolMom: Abeka parent reviews · Well-Trained Mind forum: Abeka Home School pros and cons · Cathy Duffy Reviews: Abeka Language series

All About Reading / All About Spelling

All About Learning Press

Eden earns a commission

Grades K-8 · Reading / phonics, Language arts · Prep: Open-and-go · About $160 (per family set (one-time)) · Secular / neutral

What this price covers: All About Reading Level 1: teacher's manual, student packet and three readers. You also need a Review Box ($17.95) and Letter Tiles ($25.95); levels are not tied to school years.

Try it free: Free PDF lesson samples for every level of All About Reading and All About Spelling

What moms say

Pros

  • Moms say it works especially well for struggling readers and spellers, including kids with dyslexia.
  • Lessons are scripted and open-and-go, so there is little planning.
  • Kids move at their own pace, and you can skip skills they already know.
  • Materials are reusable, so younger siblings can use them later.

Cons

  • The upfront cost is high, and you still have to cut apart the cards and tiles yourself.
  • Fluency sheets and word lists can feel long and dull.
  • Some stories feel babyish or silly to older kids.
  • A few moms felt the lessons were too light for older struggling readers, and some say the pre-reading level is little more than a letter of the week.

The forum threads are several years old, and the forum pages blocked full reads, so forum themes come from search snippets.

From independent reviews: TheHomeSchoolMom reader reviews: All About Reading · Well-Trained Mind forum: Any bad reviews about All About Reading? · Well-Trained Mind forum: All About Spelling is EXPENSIVE...or is it just me?

AmblesideOnline

AmblesideOnline Educational Foundation (AmblesideOnline Advisory)

Grades K-12 · Bible, Language arts, Science, History / social studies, Geography, Art, Music, Foreign language · Charlotte Mason · Completely free · Christian (explicit)

Completely free

Try it free: The whole curriculum is free; you only buy or borrow the books

What moms say

Pros

  • The whole plan is free online.
  • Seen as the most faithful version of Charlotte Mason's own method.
  • Rich, classic book list with short lessons and narration instead of tests.
  • Big, active online community for support.

Cons

  • Not open and go; mom has to plan the week and gather the books.
  • Many books are old and hard to read, so some kids struggle.
  • Each child follows their own year, which is hard with several kids.
  • The website feels dated, and buying books still costs money.

From independent reviews: How Do I Homeschool: Ambleside Online Curriculum Review · Well-Trained Mind Forum: AmblesideOnline thoughts · TheHomeSchoolMom: AmblesideOnline reviews

Analytical Grammar

Demme Learning (Analytical Grammar brand)

Eden earns a commission

Grades 4-12 · Language arts · Traditional / textbook · About $57 (per subject per year) · Secular / neutral

What this price covers: Level 1 set (one of five levels; each fills part of a school year), with a one-year Basic Subscription card. All five levels: $266.00.

Try it free: Free placement activities with answer keys to find the right starting point.

What moms say

Pros

  • Very thorough grammar and diagramming that keeps reviewing old skills so kids do not forget them.
  • The teacher book has answer keys and grading help, so the parent does not need to be a grammar expert.
  • Done in short, intense seasons (about 10 weeks a year), which leaves time for writing the rest of the year.
  • Many moms say diagramming finally made grammar and sentence structure click.

Cons

  • It is harder than it looks at first, and diagramming frustrates some kids.
  • The exercises are the same style every day, so kids who need variety can get bored.
  • Daily work can take 30 to 60 minutes, and grading takes the parent real time.
  • Not a full language arts program; reading, writing and spelling are separate.

From independent reviews: Cathy Duffy Reviews: Analytical Grammar · Hip Homeschool Moms: Analytical Grammar user reviews · Accidental Homeschooler: Analytical Grammar review

Answers Bible Curriculum (Answers in Genesis)

Answers in Genesis

Eden earns a commission

Grades K-5 · Bible · Traditional / textbook · About $52 (per family set (one-time)) · Christian (explicit)

What this price covers: Year 1 K to 5 teacher guide combo: guide, posters and video access. Student book combos are extra, $44.98 each (K to 1, 2 to 3, 4 to 5).

Try it free: Free sample lessons such as Joseph Rises to Power. You check out through the store at no cost to get them.

What moms say

Pros

  • One teacher guide covers all K to 5 kids, with a workbook per child, so it works well for families.
  • Lessons are meatier than most elementary Bible programs and tie the whole Bible story together.
  • Short videos, memory verse songs and a big timeline poster are included.
  • Moms say it feels written for homeschoolers even though it started as Sunday school material.

Cons

  • It is highly structured and needs a lot of parent read-aloud teaching.
  • Parents should read prep pages ahead, and the first day of each week is heavy.
  • Some content needs softening for the youngest kids.
  • Each level needs its own workbook and answer book, which adds cost for big families.

Thin independent feedback: little forum discussion of the homeschool edition found; themes lean on Cathy Duffy plus two blog reviews (one received a free copy).

From independent reviews: Cathy Duffy Reviews: Answers Bible Curriculum, Homeschool Edition · It's Not That Hard to Homeschool: Answers Bible Curriculum review · The Curriculum Choice: Answers Bible Curriculum high school review

Apologia Exploring Creation (Young Explorer elementary science)

Apologia Educational Ministries

Eden earns a commission

Grades K-6 · Science · Charlotte Mason · About $94 (per subject per year) · Christian (explicit)

What this price covers: One course (Astronomy, K to 6): textbook $55.00 plus notebooking journal $39.00; an extra child adds a journal. Videos are $79.00 extra; all eight elementary courses cost the same.

Try it free: Free Lesson 1 sample of each Young Explorer book to flip through online

What moms say

Pros

  • The warm, chatty writing and deep dive into one topic build a real love of science.
  • Lots of simple experiments and projects that use common supplies.
  • Narration, nature study and the notebooking journals fit Charlotte Mason families well.
  • One book works for several elementary ages at once.

Cons

  • The reading level is well above young kids, so parents read aloud.
  • It takes a lot of parent time and discussion. It is not independent work.
  • The notebooking journals ask young kids for a lot of writing.
  • Each book covers only one or two topics, and the extras (journals, videos, kits) add cost.

Fewer independent sources were opened for this one than for the others. Cathy Duffy's review is the main source.

From independent reviews: Cathy Duffy Reviews: Apologia's Exploring Creation Series (elementary grades) · The Curriculum Choice: Apologia Elementary Science

Grades 9-12 · Science · Traditional / textbook · About $121 (per subject per year) · Christian (explicit)

What this price covers: Biology set: the $93.00 textbook plus the $28.00 Solutions Manual and Tests (both required). The Student Notebook is extra.

Try it free: Apologia explains how to preview samples. Each course product page has a View Sample or Flip Through a Sample button.

What moms say

Pros

  • Written to the student in a clear, friendly voice, so teens can work largely on their own.
  • Many families report kids went on to do well in college science.
  • Chemistry labs use low cost equipment and supplies from the store.
  • Widely used, so co ops, tutors and used copies are easy to find.

Cons

  • Strong science students and AP bound kids often find it too light and need more.
  • Chemistry 3rd edition drew complaints about typos, poorly explained math and disorganized material.
  • Physics is hard to teach without a parent who knows the subject, and some labs are not realistic.
  • Biology needs a microscope and dissection supplies, which adds cost.

Forum threads are mostly 2012 to 2016; newer editions may differ.

From independent reviews: Cathy Duffy Reviews: Exploring Creation science series (junior and senior high) · Well-Trained Mind forum: Is Apologia rigorous enough for college prep? · Well-Trained Mind forum: Apologia Chemistry 3rd Ed, bad reviews?

Art of Problem Solving (AoPS) books/courses

Art of Problem Solving (AoPS Incorporated per copyright notice)

Grades 1-12 · Math · Traditional / textbook · About $59 (per subject per year) · Secular / neutral

What this price covers: Prealgebra text and solutions (2 books) for one course. Live online classes are sold separately.

Try it free: Each book page has a free Preview Sample chapter. Their Alcumus practice tool is 100% free too.

What moms say

Pros

  • Strong math kids love the challenge and say it is never boring.
  • It teaches deep problem solving, not just steps to memorize.
  • Free videos and the free Alcumus practice site add a lot of support.
  • Kids can work on their own, and live online classes are available.

Cons

  • Many moms say it is too hard for an average or math-anxious child.
  • Kids who get stuck can stall and feel frustrated.
  • The books are very long, and solutions and online classes cost extra.
  • There are no built-in quizzes or tests, so parents have to judge progress.

Forum threads were seen in search results; the forum blocked direct opening.

From independent reviews: Cathy Duffy Reviews: The Art of Problem Solving Math · Well-Trained Mind forum: AoPS Pre-Algebra detailed review · Well-Trained Mind forum: Thoughts on AoPS Prealgebra

ARTistic Pursuits

ARTistic Pursuits Inc.

Grades K-12 · Art · Eclectic / mixed · Prep: Open-and-go · About $632 (per family set (one-time)) · Christian-friendly

What this price covers: The full K to 3 set: 8 volumes plus their online editions.

Try it free: Each book page links a free flip-through web sample of the book. K-3 Volume 1 shown here.

What moms say

Pros

  • Easy for non-artist parents to teach, with supply lists up front.
  • Exposes kids to a huge range of media: drawing, painting, sculpture, printmaking.
  • Mixes art history and famous artists into each lesson.
  • Older levels use real art supplies and kids can work fairly independently.

Cons

  • Several moms say there is not much step-by-step drawing instruction.
  • The K to 3 books need a parent to read, demonstrate and lead every lesson.
  • Professional-grade supplies add to the cost.
  • The jump to the middle school books can be hard for kids without prior experience.

From independent reviews: Cathy Duffy Reviews: Artistic Pursuits · Well-Trained Mind: Reviews for Artistic Pursuits, please! · Well-Trained Mind: Atelier Art vs. Artistic Pursuits 1st grade

Atelier Art (Atelier Homeschool Art)

Arts Attack (copyright holder; parent site https://www.artsattack.com)

Grades K-10 · Art · Online / video · About $149 (per subject per year) · Secular / neutral

What this price covers: One level, about a year of art. The supply kit costs extra.

Screen-based

Try it free: The home page has a Preview a Sample Lesson button. It opens on the page, so there is no separate sample link.

What moms say

Pros

  • The teacher does the teaching on video, so it is fairly hands-off for mom.
  • Projects usually finish in one sitting, and one level covers about three grades so siblings can share.
  • Built-in art appreciation with famous artworks and discussion questions.
  • One basic supply kit covers most courses.

Cons

  • It is project-based rather than a true drawing skills course.
  • Videos were filmed in a classroom and need pausing for kids to work.
  • Supply kit and extra media cost more, and some household items must be gathered ahead.
  • Art print guides can be too advanced for young kids, and the full package costs extra.

Most forum feedback is old (DVD era); current online version is covered mainly by Cathy Duffy.

From independent reviews: Cathy Duffy Reviews: Atelier Online Art · Well-Trained Mind: Atelier Art vs. Artistic Pursuits 1st grade · Well-Trained Mind: Art curriculum for early elementary

Barton Reading & Spelling System

Bright Solutions for Dyslexia, Inc. (Susan Barton)

Grades K-9 · Reading / phonics, Language arts, Writing · Traditional / textbook · About $350 (per family set (one-time)) · Secular / neutral

What this price covers: Level 1 only (Phonemic Awareness, single tutor version), with tutor training, lesson plans, materials and games. Levels 3 to 10 are $400 each; shipping is $19.95 per level.

What moms say

Pros

  • Moms say the scripted lessons and teaching videos make it easy for a parent with no training to teach.
  • Parent training and support are strong, including free phone and online help.
  • It spends extra time on spelling, and the rules have catchy names kids remember.
  • It does not look childish for older kids, and finished levels can be resold.

Cons

  • Moms call it very expensive, since each level is bought separately.
  • It is a big time commitment, and finishing all ten levels can take two to four years.
  • Some kids find it boring, with not much variety from lesson to lesson.
  • It does not focus much on reading comprehension, so you may need to cover that elsewhere.

Two of the three sources are older than about 5 years (2018 and 2019).

From independent reviews: Fun With Mama: Barton Reading and Spelling review · Understood: Barton System, what you need to know · Homeschooling with Dyslexia: Comparison of the top 4 Orton-Gillingham programs

Berean Builders elementary science (Science in the... series)

Berean Builders Publishing Incorporated

Eden earns a commission

Grades K-6 · Science · About $49 (per subject per year) · Christian (explicit)

What this price covers: One course (Science in the Ancient World): textbook plus the parent's Helps & Hints book, about 90 hours of lessons. Supplies are household items.

Try it free: Free text sample PDFs for every elementary course, plus supply lists

What moms say

Pros

  • Every lesson starts with a hands-on experiment, and moms say the experiments actually work.
  • Short lessons. The whole family can do one book together, with extra notebook work for older kids.
  • Teaching science through history, in the order it was discovered, ties in nicely with history studies.
  • Low cost. Supplies are mostly household items.

Cons

  • The text can be wordy and over the heads of first and second graders, so most moms place it at grades 3 to 6.
  • Topics jump around because of the history order.
  • A few experiments need odd items, such as a feather, iodine or a live earthworm, or need sunny weather.
  • The answer book (Helps and Hints) is sold separately, and tests are short or optional.

The forum pages blocked full reads, so forum themes come from search snippets.

From independent reviews: Cathy Duffy Reviews: Science in History Series (Berean Builders) · Well-Trained Mind forum: Do you still love Science in the Beginning? · Reasons to Believe: Curriculum Review of Jay Wile's Science in the... Series

Biology 101 (Westfield Studios)

Westfield Studios (The 101 Series)

Grades 9-12 · Science · Online / video · About $165 (per family set (one-time)) · Christian (explicit)

What this price covers: Streaming bundle: Biology 101 videos, 134-page guidebook, student notebook and lab report notepad. The videos alone are $84.95.

Screen-based

Try it free: The first video segment is a free preview on the streaming page. A free guidebook PDF sample is offered by email on the home page.

What moms say

Pros

  • Engaging video with strong production and a funny, likeable host.
  • Easy for parents: press play, then do the activities.
  • Teaches standard biology content including current classification.

Cons

  • Only about 4.5 hours of video, so it is not a full year on its own.
  • To count as a credit you must add the PDF assignments and outside reading.
  • Many moms use it as a supplement next to a textbook rather than as the main course.
  • The material was produced around 2006, so it can feel dated.

Many blog reviews came from a 2016 review crew that received free copies; forum feedback is older.

From independent reviews: Cathy Duffy Reviews: Biology 101 DVD set · Well-Trained Mind forum: Biology 101 from Westfield Studios, what's it like? · ABCs and Sweet Tea: Biology 101 review

BJU Press Homeschool

BJU Press

Eden earns a commission

Grades K-12 · Bible, Language arts, Reading / phonics, Writing, Math, Science, History / social studies · Traditional / textbook · About $1037 (per child per year) · Christian (explicit)

What this price covers: 3rd grade Complete Grade Textbook Kit: the essential student and teacher materials. Bible is $118.10 extra; an extra child's student kit is $538.40.

Try it free: Free math and reading skills checks to help place your child; no free trial of video lessons found

What moms say

Pros

  • Video teachers are engaging, and some moms say it feels like a private tutor.
  • Academically solid, with math and high school courses seen as challenging.
  • A full, clear plan so mom does not build a schedule from scratch.

Cons

  • Expensive, especially the video program for several kids.
  • Still parent heavy: grading and managing teacher books takes time.
  • Long school days, and some find the videos dated or a few lessons confusing.

Parent reviews are mostly from about 2010 to 2018; Cathy Duffy reviews cover single courses, not the whole program.

From independent reviews: TheHomeSchoolMom: BJU Press parent reviews · Hip Homeschool Moms: BJU Press user reviews · Cathy Duffy Reviews: Pre-Algebra (BJU Press)

Grades 8-12 · History / social studies, Life skills · Literature-based · About $36 (per child per year) · Secular / neutral

What this price covers: Two books: Whatever Happened to Penny Candy? ($16.95) and A Bluestocking Guide: Economics ($18.95), bought separately.

What moms say

Pros

  • Moms say it explains economics clearly enough for both kids and adults to enjoy.
  • Letters from Uncle Eric to his nephew make economics engaging for readers with no background.
  • It is short, and reading a chapter a day worked even for one mom's nine year old.
  • A glossary of bold terms and a further reading section help kids go deeper.

Cons

  • One parent wished for more basic definitions of economic terms early on.
  • It has a strong libertarian and conservative slant, and one reviewer suggested pairing it with a Christian worldview text.
  • One Christian reviewer wished it rooted free markets in Christianity rather than a general higher law.
  • The series is geared to older students, though some moms used it with younger kids.

Thin evidence: one free-copy post, one affiliate post with no cons, and one 2010 retailer customer review.

From independent reviews: Teach Beside Me: Economics for kids · Northern Nester: Whatever Happened to Penny Candy? living book review · Exodus Books: Whatever Happened to Penny Candy? customer review

Bob Books

Bob Books (Maslen family), distributed by Scholastic, Inc.

Eden earns a commission

Grades K-1 · Reading / phonics · Traditional / textbook · About $18 (per family set (one-time)) · Secular / neutral

What this price covers: Set 1 (Beginning Readers): a box of 12 books, 12 pages each; readers, not a full curriculum. Listed $17.99, on sale at $15.99 when checked.

Try it free: Free printables: coloring pages, sight word games and a reward chart. No free book samples.

What moms say

Pros

  • The tiny books give a beginning reader a quick, real sense of success.
  • Sets are cheap, and there is basically no prep.
  • The steps between sets are small and steady.
  • Most words can be sounded out, with very few sight words.

Cons

  • They are readers, not a phonics program, so you still need something that teaches the sounds.
  • Kids memorize the short books or guess from the pictures instead of truly reading.
  • Many kids find the stories dull.
  • The series ends early, around second grade.

From independent reviews: Well-Trained Mind forum: Are BOB books and/or flash cards worth it? · Imagination Soup: Pros and Cons of Teaching Reading With BOB Books · The Homeschool Mom: Bob Books reader reviews

BookShark

BookShark

Grades K-8 · History / social studies, Geography, Language arts, Reading / phonics, Writing, Science, Math · Literature-based · Prep: Open-and-go · About $1041 (per child per year) · Secular / neutral

What this price covers: Level C All-Subject Package (grades 2 to 4): 36-week guides, history, readers, language arts, science and math. BookShark's listing page showed $925.77 the same day.

Try it free: Free 3-week sample of every Instructor's Guide (history, science, language arts), plus a free 1-week trial of BookShark Virtual

What moms say

Pros

  • Built around real, engaging books that can win over reluctant readers.
  • Secular, faith-neutral option among literature-based programs.
  • Fully scheduled guides that still feel flexible.
  • You can buy just the guides and borrow books from the library to save money.

Cons

  • Full packages are expensive, near $1,000 for some levels.
  • Lots of reading aloud, so it takes a lot of mom's time.
  • Science and writing feel weaker to some moms and get supplemented.
  • Book picks and history order are uneven in some levels.

Thin: few unpaid parent reviews (only two on TheHomeSchoolMom), and some bloggers received free product.

From independent reviews: TheHomeSchoolMom: BookShark reviews · How Do I Homeschool: BookShark Curriculum Review · Monkey and Mom: BookShark curriculum review, Level G

Brave Writer

Brave Writer

Grades K-12 · Writing, Language arts · Eclectic / mixed · About $180 (per subject per year) · Secular / neutral

What this price covers: The Arrow for 2026 to 2027: nine monthly guides for ages 11 to 12 (older pages said 8 to 11). Price and contents not confirmed on the publisher's page.

Try it free: Free sampler of 10 PDF downloads across their writing products. Asks for your email.

What moms say

Pros

  • It helps reluctant kids enjoy writing by putting their ideas first.
  • Moms say it changed how they teach writing and gave them more confidence.
  • Literature-based copywork and dictation fit easily into a relaxed, read-aloud home.
  • The online classes get good marks from many families.

Cons

  • It is not open and go; the mom has to plan and study the method.
  • Many find it expensive for what you get, especially the classes.
  • Kids who want clear step-by-step assignments can feel lost.
  • Moms who want a set schedule find it too loose.

From independent reviews: Well-Trained Mind forum: Opinions if you use/have used Brave Writer? · Well-Trained Mind forum: Why Bravewriter costs so much (Writer's Jungle) · Cathy Duffy Reviews: Brave Writer

Breaking the Barrier Spanish

Breaking the Barrier, Inc.

Grades 6-12 · Foreign language · Traditional / textbook · About $145 (per child per year) · Secular / neutral

What this price covers: Beginner A homeschool package: book, answer key, tests, quizzes, dictionary and 12 months of online access. The publisher's pages show both $145 and $135.

What moms say

Pros

  • Grammar is explained clearly, and each lesson pairs it with a good variety of practice exercises.
  • The large-print worktext feels less intimidating than many high school language textbooks.
  • Online audio from native speakers, short videos and self-checking exercises add listening practice.
  • The middle school version covers first-year material at half the speed, giving younger students more time.

Cons

  • The high school course moves quickly, so a true beginner with no Spanish may struggle.
  • Speaking practice needs a partner who knows some Spanish, since the program cannot check spoken answers.
  • It leans toward reading and writing, so kids who want conversation will need outside practice.
  • The middle school books teach vosotros, which is less common in Mexico and much of Latin America.

Both reviews are from Cathy Duffy Reviews; Well-Trained Mind threads were blocked, and no other independent family reviews could be opened.

From independent reviews: Cathy Duffy Reviews: Breaking the Barrier Courses, Spanish and French · Cathy Duffy Reviews: Breaking the Barrier Spanish for Middle School

Building Thinking Skills (The Critical Thinking Co.)

The Critical Thinking Co.

Eden earns a commission

Grades K-1 · Logic · Traditional / textbook · About $33 (per child per year) · Secular / neutral

What this price covers: One student book (Primary level). Price from a retailer.

Try it free: Free printable sample pages for every book. Click View Sample Pages on each product page.

What moms say

Pros

  • It covers a wide range of thinking and logic skills in one book.
  • Lessons are short, need little prep, and include an answer key.
  • Many moms like it as gentle test prep and a base for later logic.

Cons

  • Sections get repetitive, and some kids get bored.
  • The workbook is huge and can overwhelm a child.
  • It is a supplement, so it adds to the school day rather than replacing a subject.

Most feedback is short blog reviews; repetition and size complaints come mainly from retailer customer comments and a gifted-parent forum.

From independent reviews: Cathy Duffy Reviews: Critical Thinking Company · The Unlikely Homeschool: Building Thinking Skills Level 2 review · The Curriculum Choice: Building Thinking Skills

Catholic Heritage Curricula

Catholic Heritage Curricula (CHC)

Grades K-12 · Bible, Language arts, Reading / phonics, Writing, Science, History / social studies, Geography, Art · Eclectic / mixed · Prep: Open-and-go · About $365 (per child per year) · Christian (explicit)

What this price covers: Third Grade Core Kit: lesson plans, answer keys and core texts, without math or literature books. Other grades cost different amounts.

Try it free: Grade-level flipbooks (preschool to 8th) give a book-by-book look inside and help check placement. There is also a Free Resources page at chcweb.com/free-resources/.

What moms say

Pros

  • Moms describe it as gentle and easy to use, with a peaceful pace for young kids.
  • Daily lesson plans are organized and leave a light day each week in the early grades.
  • Art, music and character lessons are built in for the younger grades.
  • Complete grade packages cost less than many full programs.

Cons

  • Each child does their own grade level, which gets hard with many kids.
  • The scheduled math is older and can lag behind newer programs for a strong math kid.
  • Some parents call the grammar books weak, and full sets add up in cost.
  • Upper grades need more planning by mom, and high school is a do-it-yourself guide.

Specific complaints are thin; cost and grammar remarks come from a few short parent reviews.

From independent reviews: Cathy Duffy Reviews: Catholic Heritage Curricula Complete Grade Level Programs · Well-Trained Mind forum: CHC - what do you love? · TheHomeSchoolMom: Catholic Heritage Curriculum reviews

Christian Light Education

Christian Light Publications

Grades K-12 · Bible, Reading / phonics, Language arts, Math, Science, History / social studies · Traditional / textbook · About $56 (per subject per year) · Christian (explicit)

What this price covers: Grade 3 math only: 10 LightUnits (170 lessons). The Teacher's Guide ($24.95) and other subjects are separate; an extra child needs a second $55.50 set.

Try it free: Placement tests for math and language arts; buy in print or download

What moms say

Pros

  • Math is a standout, with steady daily review at a low price.
  • Inexpensive, clear workbooks that kids can often work through on their own.
  • Language arts is thorough and good for kids who need lots of review.

Cons

  • Science and social studies feel dry, and many moms use something else for those.
  • Lots of workbook pages, which can feel repetitive.
  • Reading stories do not grab every child.
  • High school beyond Algebra 1 is weaker or not fully their own program.

Most reviews are from about 2010 to 2014 with a few from 2019 to 2020.

From independent reviews: Cathy Duffy Reviews: Christian Light Education Mathematics, grades 1-8 · TheHomeSchoolMom: Christian Light parent reviews · Well-Trained Mind forum: Opinions on Christian Light Education?

Compass Classroom

Compass Classroom

Grades 6-12 · Bible, History / social studies, Geography, Language arts, Writing, Foreign language, Math, Science, Logic, Art, Music, Health / PE · Online / video · About $890 (per family per year) · Christian (explicit)

What this price covers: Family membership for one year: 1 parent and up to 4 students. Monthly it is $89; an Individual plan is $490 a year.

Screen-based

Try it free: Membership starts with a 2-week free trial; billing begins after unless you cancel. Page blocked our direct check, confirmed from search listing of the publisher's own pages.

What moms say

Pros

  • One membership opens 40 plus video courses, which reviewers call a strong value for families.
  • Teens like the engaging teachers, especially the history and Visual Latin courses.
  • Many courses are full year with assignments, tests and answer keys.
  • A free trial lets you test it before paying.

Cons

  • Parents must grade written work unless they pay extra for the grading service.
  • Paid grading is expensive per course and adds up fast.
  • It does not cover every high school subject, and some courses are only supplements.
  • There are fewer options for younger kids.

Thin evidence. Little independent parent feedback on the membership as a whole was found; this rests mostly on Cathy Duffy's reviews.

From independent reviews: Cathy Duffy Reviews: Compass Classroom Membership · Cathy Duffy Reviews: Visual Latin

Easy Peasy All-in-One Homeschool

Lee Giles (Easy Peasy All-in-One Homeschool)

Grades K-8 · Bible, Language arts, Reading / phonics, Math, Science, History / social studies, Art, Music, Health / PE · Online / video · Prep: Open-and-go · Completely free · Christian (explicit)

Completely free

Screen-based

Try it free: The whole online curriculum is free; optional printed workbooks are sold separately

What moms say

Pros

  • Completely free, covering most subjects from preschool up.
  • Very little prep, and good readers can do much of it on their own.
  • Uses real books, narration and picture study, not just worksheets.

Cons

  • Hard to know if kids really finished the online work.
  • Lots of screen time and links out to many sites, which some find messy.
  • Quality is uneven, and the high school level is seen as weak.
  • Moms are split on the reading method.

From independent reviews: Cathy Duffy Reviews: Easy Peasy All in One Homeschool · TheHomeSchoolMom: Easy Peasy parent reviews · Well-Trained Mind forum: Quality of Easy Peasy high school?

Coming soon · Planned for late 2027

Eden's Table: Cultivators (grades 6-8)

Rooted in Faith Ventures LLC

Grades 6-8 · Science, Bible · Charlotte Mason · Christian (explicit)

Ours Eden's Table is our own curriculum. It's in this guide by the same rules as everything else.

Eden's Table for grades 6-8 is on the way, made the same Charlotte Mason way as our K-5 sets. Join the waitlist and be the first to know.

Coming soon · Planned for 2028

Eden's Table: Practitioners (grades 9-12)

Rooted in Faith Ventures LLC

Grades 9-12 · Science, Bible · Charlotte Mason · Christian (explicit)

Ours Eden's Table is our own curriculum. It's in this guide by the same rules as everything else.

Eden's Table for grades 9-12 is on the way, made the same Charlotte Mason way as our K-5 sets. Join the waitlist and be the first to know.

Grades 3-5 · Science, Bible · Charlotte Mason · Prep: Open-and-go · About $249 (per family set (one-time)) · Christian (explicit)

What this price covers: Printed Seedlings set (grades 3 to 5), one-time, plus $12 shipping. Siblings in the band share the Teacher's Guide; each extra child adds a $39.99 notebook.

Ours Eden's Table is our own curriculum. It's in this guide by the same rules as everything else.

Try it free: A free first week to try at home: sign up on the page.

What families say

Shared with permission by families who used the free sample. Eden's Table is our own curriculum, so these aren't independent reviews.

“I am a mother who has been homeschooling kids for over 18 years. I had the opportunity to review some of the lessons in the elementary grades and these lessons are amazing for someone who wants to add herbs/gardening plus faith based lessons to their curriculum. As a homesteading family, I would have loved to have something like this when my kids were little. The balance of faith and herb/gardening is perfect, it is a complete lesson and well thought out. The lessons for younger kids are easy to understand and get a little more in depth when moving up a level. Each week you study a new herb/plant and everything is included for the week. With the stories, table cards, questions, scriptures, recipes, and everything together it covers core subjects like math, reading, faith, and herbs/plants; this is a great addition to a homeschooling curriculum.”

– Amanda, homeschooling 18 years · Dream Chasers Homestead

“I just wanted you to see how into it they are! No complaining and actually asking to do their ‘learning’!!”

– Kati, former nurse and paramedic

“This curriculum is truly amazing! I have numerous herbal books from all sorts of authors, and this curriculum truly puts it into bite-size chunks of information while still incorporating incredible vocabulary, concepts, and quality stories. The fact that you are incorporating all these other topics beyond just herbal information is truly incredible as well. I truly love everything about it so far and can't wait until it launches! It is exactly what I was looking for and I am so excited for what will unfold in the years to come as we dive deep as a family.”

– Kendria Scriver, curriculum writer

“Ahhhhhh I just spent the last few hours poring over the free sample you sent us. This curriculum is absolutely fantastic. I cannot wait to buy this in the fall. This will be our kids favourite curriculum to explore.”

– Coralee, who read the free sample cover to cover

“This is a beautiful curriculum to start. I've just begun reading our teaching guide.”

– Brooke, Clarksville, TN

“LOVE this!”

– Ems Glenn

Grades K-2 · Science, Bible · Charlotte Mason · Prep: Open-and-go · About $249 (per family set (one-time)) · Christian (explicit)

What this price covers: Printed Sprouts set (K to 2), one-time, plus $12 shipping. Siblings in the band share the Teacher's Guide; each extra child adds a $39.99 notebook.

Ours Eden's Table is our own curriculum. It's in this guide by the same rules as everything else.

Try it free: A free first week to try at home: sign up on the page.

What families say

Shared with permission by families who used the free sample. Eden's Table is our own curriculum, so these aren't independent reviews.

“I am a mother who has been homeschooling kids for over 18 years. I had the opportunity to review some of the lessons in the elementary grades and these lessons are amazing for someone who wants to add herbs/gardening plus faith based lessons to their curriculum. As a homesteading family, I would have loved to have something like this when my kids were little. The balance of faith and herb/gardening is perfect, it is a complete lesson and well thought out. The lessons for younger kids are easy to understand and get a little more in depth when moving up a level. Each week you study a new herb/plant and everything is included for the week. With the stories, table cards, questions, scriptures, recipes, and everything together it covers core subjects like math, reading, faith, and herbs/plants; this is a great addition to a homeschooling curriculum.”

– Amanda, homeschooling 18 years · Dream Chasers Homestead

“I just wanted you to see how into it they are! No complaining and actually asking to do their ‘learning’!!”

– Kati, former nurse and paramedic

“This curriculum is truly amazing! I have numerous herbal books from all sorts of authors, and this curriculum truly puts it into bite-size chunks of information while still incorporating incredible vocabulary, concepts, and quality stories. The fact that you are incorporating all these other topics beyond just herbal information is truly incredible as well. I truly love everything about it so far and can't wait until it launches! It is exactly what I was looking for and I am so excited for what will unfold in the years to come as we dive deep as a family.”

– Kendria Scriver, curriculum writer

“Ahhhhhh I just spent the last few hours poring over the free sample you sent us. This curriculum is absolutely fantastic. I cannot wait to buy this in the fall. This will be our kids favourite curriculum to explore.”

– Coralee, who read the free sample cover to cover

“This is a beautiful curriculum to start. I've just begun reading our teaching guide.”

– Brooke, Clarksville, TN

“LOVE this!”

– Ems Glenn

Elemental Science

Elemental Science

Eden earns a commission

Grades K-12 · Science · Classical · About $35 (per subject per year) · Secular / neutral

What this price covers: One 36-week K to 2 set (teacher guide and student workbook). Encyclopedias and supplies are extra.

Try it free: Free sample lessons and excerpts for each program on one samples page.

What moms say

Pros

  • Open and go: each week is laid out with a notebook page and an experiment page, so prep is light.
  • Most experiments use things you already have at home, and a supply kit is sold for the harder items.
  • Moms often say it is the one science program that actually gets done each week.
  • Covers all the sciences from early elementary through high school in a steady sequence.

Cons

  • Some kids find it heavy on reading, cutting and pasting, with fewer hands on experiments than hoped.
  • The schedule can feel jumpy and some notebook work feels like busywork.
  • The spine and library books are bought separately, which adds cost and hunting.
  • Families disagree on whether it is truly secular, so check the book list against your own needs.

Most forum threads are from 2012 to 2016, so the current line may differ.

From independent reviews: Cathy Duffy Reviews: Elemental Science Classic Series · Well-Trained Mind forum: What's your thoughts about Elemental Science? · Well-Trained Mind forum: Compare Noeo, R.E.A.L. Science, and Elemental Science

Ellen McHenry's Basement Workshop

Ellen McHenry's Basement Workshop (Ellen J. McHenry)

Grades 3-10 · Science, Geography, Art, History / social studies, Language arts · Unit study · About $19 (per family set (one-time)) · Christian-friendly

What this price covers: One unit (Botany in 8 Lessons, download). Not a full year.

Try it free: Big free downloads section, including a full free Composition and Design course. Paid curricula like Cells, Elements and Brain offer free sample chapters on their product pages.

What moms say

Pros

  • Moms rave about the writing, which explains hard topics in a way kids understand.
  • Hands on and multi sensory, with games and clever experiments that keep it from feeling dry.
  • Inexpensive downloads, and some units are free.
  • Whole families often enjoy the units together, especially The Elements.

Cons

  • Units are short mini courses, not a full year of science.
  • Many units are really middle school level, so they can be too hard for young elementary kids.
  • Some families love the idea but struggle to get it done consistently.
  • Secular families note some topics are skipped, and the author's views show more in a few units.

From independent reviews: Well-Trained Mind forum: How do you use Ellen McHenry science? · Cathy Duffy Reviews: Botany in 8 Lessons · Well-Trained Mind forum: Ellen McHenry Elements, what age/grade?

Essentials in Writing

Essentials in Writing

Grades 1-12 · Writing, Language arts · Online / video · About $119 (per subject per year) · Secular / neutral

What this price covers: Level 3, print and digital: student book, teacher handbook and video lessons. Digital only is $99; adding the assessment booklet makes it $139.

Screen-based

Try it free: Try up to 4 levels before you buy, no credit card. Fill out a short form. Free placement tool also offered.

What moms say

Pros

  • Video lessons do the teaching, which saves the mom time.
  • It breaks writing into small, doable steps.
  • Older kids can work fairly independently.
  • It is reasonably priced.

Cons

  • Many find it formulaic and dry.
  • It is not very challenging for strong writers.
  • Moms complain about home-video quality, like a wobbly or blurry camera.
  • The workbook is not much use without the videos.

Most forum posts are 8 to 14 years old; the video quality complaint may be outdated if lessons were re-filmed.

From independent reviews: Well-Trained Mind forum: Essentials in Writing, used it? liked it? hated it? · Well-Trained Mind forum: Reviews on Essentials in Writing? · Cathy Duffy Reviews: Essentials in Writing

Grades 8-12 · Language arts, Writing · Literature-based · About $39 (per subject per year) · Christian-friendly

What this price covers: One guide (E1, Introduction to Literature), print. The eBook is $29.00.

Try it free: Free sample lesson PDF linked from the Excellence in Literature home page.

What moms say

Pros

  • Seen as a serious, college prep literature course built on classic books.
  • Designed for the student to work through mostly on their own.
  • Teaches students to write real literary essays, with a writing handbook to back it up.
  • One guide can cover several years (grades 8 to 12), so it is good value for the price.

Cons

  • The workload is heavy, about an hour or more of reading and writing a day, and falling behind is hard to fix.
  • The intro level can be too much for a young middle schooler.
  • There are no comprehension questions, so the parent has to find other ways to check understanding and grade essays.
  • You also need a separate writer's handbook.

Thin independent evidence. Most reviews found are 2011 review-crew posts written with a free copy; forum threads could not be opened and no recent independent reviews turned up.

From independent reviews: The Old Schoolhouse: Excellence in Literature review · Well-Trained Mind forum: Anyone using Excellence in Literature with an 8th grader? · Homeschool Review blog: Excellence in Literature

Grades 9-12 · History / social studies, Language arts, Bible · Literature-based · About $75 (per child per year) · Christian (explicit)

What this price covers: A one-semester course: lesson book plus We Hold These Truths, listed $75.00 and shown at $70.00. The bundle with literature and review pack is $155.00.

What moms say

Pros

  • Moms say the writing is lively and easier to read than most government textbooks.
  • A teen can work through it alone, since each lesson lists its own assignments.
  • Students read founding documents and speeches in a companion book that ties the course together.
  • An optional literature add-on lets a student earn half an English credit as well.

Cons

  • The textbook carries a lot of personal opinion from a conservative, limited-government view, which may not fit every family.
  • Plan on about an hour a day, or about two hours with the English credit.
  • Some of the literature books include profanity and drinking, so parents may want to preview them.
  • Quizzes, exams and daily review questions come in a separate pack, sold apart from the core books.

One blog post used a Timberdoodle-supplied copy of an older edition (2018), and the other carries a general sponsored-content disclosure.

From independent reviews: Cathy Duffy Reviews: Exploring Government (2023 edition) · Weird Unsocialized Homeschoolers: Notgrass Exploring Government review · Family, Faith, and Fridays: Government Gone Wrong

Exploring Nature with Children

Raising Little Shoots

Grades K-8 · Science, Art, Language arts · Charlotte Mason · About $19 (per family set (one-time)) · Christian-friendly

What this price covers: One 236-page PDF, a one-time purchase. The author wrote it to be used with several ages at once.

Try it free: The buy page has a Sample link (a Payhip preview). There is also a free Gentle Start getting-started guide under Free Resources.

What moms say

Pros

  • Open and go weekly plans that follow the seasons, so you always know what to look for outside.
  • Each week adds a poem, a piece of art and book ideas, which fits nicely into morning time.
  • Works for a wide age range at once, and moms reuse it for years.
  • Inexpensive compared with most full science programs.

Cons

  • Mostly observation and drawing, with fewer hands on activities than some kids want.
  • Works best where the seasons change clearly; warm or urban areas need to adapt.
  • The number of extension options can feel overwhelming at first.
  • Many published reviews come from bloggers given a free copy, so truly independent feedback is limited.

Few critical reviews exist; cons are drawn from scattered forum comments and the Cathy Duffy review.

From independent reviews: Cathy Duffy Reviews: Exploring Nature with Children · Well-Trained Mind forum: Exploring Nature with Children for science · Well-Trained Mind forum: Favorite Nature Study?

First Form Latin (Memoria Press)

Memoria Press

Eden earns a commission

Grades 5-12 · Foreign language · Classical · About $153 (per subject per year) · Christian (explicit)

What this price covers: Complete set: student text, teacher manual, workbook, quizzes and tests, plus streaming video lessons. Listed $152.60; shown today at $136.89.

Screen-based

Try it free: Product page has free sample PDFs of the workbook, teacher manual, key, quizzes and flashcards.

What moms say

Pros

  • Very systematic, with lots of drill and review, so grammar and vocabulary stick.
  • A gentler pace than high school Latin programs, good for grades 5 and up or junior high.
  • The DVD lessons help parents who never studied Latin.
  • Detailed teacher manual.

Cons

  • Heavy on memorizing and drilling, which some kids find dry.
  • Not an independent course; it is built around recitation with a parent.
  • Parents without Latin should work through each lesson ahead of time.
  • Less translation reading than some other programs, and some moms found the lesson plans thin.

Forum threads were seen in search results but could not be opened, so forum themes come from result snippets.

From independent reviews: Cathy Duffy Reviews: Latina Christiana, Prima Latina, and Form Latin series · Well-Trained Mind forum: First Form Latin · Well-Trained Mind forum: How did you schedule Memoria Press First Form Latin?

First Language Lessons (Well-Trained Mind Press)

Well-Trained Mind Press (author Jessie Wise)

Eden earns a commission

Grades 1-4 · Language arts · Classical · About $19 (per family set (one-time)) · Secular / neutral

What this price covers: The Level 1 book. Price from a retailer.

Try it free: Free sample PDF of Level 1, linked from the Well-Trained Mind product page.

What moms say

Pros

  • Short scripted lessons, often 5 to 15 minutes, with no planning.
  • Levels 1 and 2 come in one reusable book, so it is cheap for several kids.
  • Poems, narration and memorized definitions build a strong grammar base early.
  • It pairs smoothly with Writing With Ease from the same publisher.

Cons

  • Many moms find it dry and very repetitive, so they combine or skip lessons.
  • It is all oral and parent-led, with little for the child to do on their own.
  • Level 3 jumps up in writing and diagramming, which some kids find hard.
  • It covers grammar only, so you still need spelling and writing.

From independent reviews: Well-Trained Mind forum: What Language/Grammar Program have you Loved/Hated · Well-Trained Mind forum: First Language Lessons · Real Life at Home: Curriculum Review, First Language Lessons

Five in a Row

Five in a Row (Five in a Row Publishing)

Grades K-6 · Language arts, Art, Math, Science, History / social studies, Geography · Unit study · About $49 (per family set (one-time)) · Christian (explicit)

What this price covers: The Volume 1 manual (ages 5 to 9). The picture books are not included.

Try it free: Free sample of over 80 pages with five complete unit studies across all levels, plus book lists.

What moms say

Pros

  • Moms love the gentle, cozy feel of reading a great picture book together all week.
  • It introduces kids to classic children's literature that is worth owning.
  • Hands-on activities across subjects suit active little learners.
  • One guide can be used with several young children, so it stretches the cost.

Cons

  • It is not open and go; mom must read ahead, pick activities and gather supplies.
  • Math and phonics must be bought separately.
  • Some kids get bored hearing the same book five days in a row, especially older ones.
  • Finding every book takes library trips or extra purchases, and a few titles are out of print.

From independent reviews: Cathy Duffy Reviews: Five in a Row · TheHomeSchoolMom: Five in a Row reviews · Well-Trained Mind forum: What is it about Five In A Row?

Fix It! Grammar (Institute for Excellence in Writing)

Institute for Excellence in Writing (IEW)

Eden earns a commission

Grades 4-12 · Language arts · Literature-based · About $29 (per subject per year) · Christian-friendly

What this price covers: One level's teacher and student combo; each level is a full year of grammar.

Try it free: First three weeks free after a short form. Sample PDFs for all six books are on iew.com/fix.

What moms say

Pros

  • Lessons are short, about 15 minutes a day, four days a week.
  • Kids learn grammar by fixing sentences in a running story, which many moms say sticks better than workbook drills.
  • Easy for the parent to teach, and many kids can do it fairly independently.
  • Pairs well with IEW writing because the two use the same terms.

Cons

  • Some kids need more practice and review than the few daily sentences give, and moms on forums disagree about whether it is enough on its own.
  • It does not teach writing, so you still need a separate writing program.
  • Works best for kids who already read well and enjoy editing puzzles.

Many blog reviews were written with a free review copy; forum threads were seen in search results but could not be opened.

From independent reviews: Cathy Duffy Reviews: Fix It! Grammar Series · Well-Trained Mind forum: Is Fix It Grammar really enough? · Confessions of a Homeschooler: Fix It Grammar review and comments

Grades 9-12 · Life skills · Online / video · Prep: Open-and-go · About $90 (per child per year) · Christian (explicit)

What this price covers: Textbook plus one year of streaming. Each extra student is $29.99.

Screen-based

Try it free: Free sample PDFs for the homeschool edition: pacing guide, a lesson guide, student text, activity and devotional from Chapter 1.

What moms say

Pros

  • Teens find the videos funny and engaging, and some call it a favorite class.
  • It covers real-life money skills like budgeting, credit, insurance, taxes and investing.
  • Guided notes and short videos make it easy for a teen to work alone.
  • It fits neatly into one semester for a half credit.

Cons

  • Grading is a weak spot: written answers are marked complete no matter what is typed, and activities must be graded by mom.
  • Answer keys are thin, with many answers that say they will vary.
  • The textbook mostly repeats the videos, which some students find tedious.
  • It teaches one specific money philosophy and has little true economics.

The Unlikely Homeschool review covers the older DVD and workbook edition; Cathy Duffy covers the current online edition.

From independent reviews: Cathy Duffy Reviews: Foundations in Personal Finance, Homeschool Edition · The Unlikely Homeschool: Foundations in Personal Finance pros and cons · Well-Trained Mind forum: Thoughts on Dave Ramsey's Foundations in Personal Finance?

Gather Round Homeschool

Gather 'Round Homeschool USA, Inc.

Grades K-12 · Bible, History / social studies, Science, Language arts, Art · Unit study · Prep: Open-and-go · Christian (explicit)

Try it free: Free sample library with one-day samples of many units to download

What moms say

Pros

  • Easy to teach all ages together, with each level's day spelled out.
  • Beautiful, colorful materials that many moms enjoy.
  • Open and go, and a free sample week lets you try it first.

Cons

  • Can feel worksheet heavy and more informational than hands-on.
  • Math is not included past the early levels.
  • Some find the upper and high school levels too light, and a few report errors.
  • Printing and buying many units adds up in cost.

Newer program, so fewer long-term reviews; mostly forum posts plus one Cathy Duffy review.

From independent reviews: Cathy Duffy Reviews: Gather 'Round Homeschool · Well-Trained Mind forum: Anyone looked at Gather Round yet? · Well-Trained Mind forum: Gather 'Round

God's Design Science series

Master Books (series originally from Answers in Genesis; now sold as the MB Edition)

Eden earns a commission

Grades K-8 · Science · Traditional / textbook · Prep: Open-and-go · About $101 (per subject per year) · Christian (explicit)

What this price covers: God's Design for Life set: one student book and one teacher guide for a one-year life science course. Listed $100.98; shown at $80.78 on Nov 18.

Try it free: Free A Look Inside PDF preview on each book page

What moms say

Pros

  • One set teaches several ages, with harder add-ons for older kids.
  • Every lesson has a simple hands-on experiment.
  • Schedules, supply lists and answer keys are included, so prep is light.
  • Full-color books with nice pictures and short biographies of scientists.

Cons

  • It is reading-heavy, and some sections pile on new vocabulary, so younger kids can struggle.
  • Some moms wanted more hands-on work and added experiment books.
  • The mixed-age setup can feel awkward with only one child.
  • Worksheets and quizzes are weak or need copying, and a few supplies are hard to find.

TheHomeSchoolMom has only about eight reader reviews.

From independent reviews: Cathy Duffy Reviews: God's Design Science Series · TheHomeSchoolMom reader reviews: God's Design for Science · Well-Trained Mind forum: God's Design for Science, best price? reviews?

Grapevine Studies

Grapevine Studies

Grades K-12 · Bible, Art · Eclectic / mixed · Prep: Open-and-go · About $75 (per family set (one-time)) · Christian (explicit)

What this price covers: The teacher book only. Student books are $34.95 each.

Try it free: Download a sample lesson for each level, from PreK through middle school, plus the topical studies.

What moms say

Pros

  • Stick figure drawing gets kids reading Scripture with their hands busy, and any parent can draw stick figures.
  • Builds a clear Bible timeline from Genesis on.
  • Easy to teach with little prep.
  • Multi-level books let several ages work together.

Cons

  • Lessons can run long, so many moms split one lesson over several days.
  • Not every child connects with drawing; one mom found narration held her son's attention better.
  • It sticks to the text and facts, so families wanting more application or discussion may add to it.

Thin independent evidence: no Cathy Duffy review found, most blog reviews were free review-crew copies, and forum posts are 10+ years old.

From independent reviews: Well-Trained Mind: Awana homeschool or Grapevine Studies? · Our Homeschool Notebook: Grapevine Studies review · Hip Homeschool Moms: Grapevine Studies review

Handbook of Nature Study / Outdoor Hour Challenge

Southern Hodgepodge, L.L.C. (Homeschool Nature Study)

Eden earns a commission

Grades K-12 · Science, Art · Charlotte Mason · About $20 (monthly subscription) · Christian-friendly

What this price covers: The monthly membership. The Handbook of Nature Study book is separate.

Try it free: Free sample lessons listed at $0 in the shop. Many weekly Outdoor Hour Challenge posts are free on the blog. Full plans need a paid membership.

What moms say

Pros

  • Moms say the challenges are the gentlest way to finally start nature study and actually do it.
  • Short, step by step prompts tell you what to look for outside and what to read in the Handbook afterward.
  • Pairs naturally with a nature journal and works for all ages at once.
  • The Handbook itself is called a must have reference for the science shelf.

Cons

  • The Handbook is a huge book with tiny print and few photos, written to the parent, so it is a reference rather than something kids read.
  • Some moms say the volume of challenges became too much and they drifted to printing a page here and there.
  • The challenges moved from a free blog to a paid membership, which confuses newcomers about what to buy.
  • It needs a parent willing to get outside regularly and read up ahead of time.

Independent feedback on the current paid membership is thin; most comments are about the older free challenges and the Handbook itself.

From independent reviews: Well-Trained Mind forum: Handbook of Nature Study? · Simply Charlotte Mason forum: Outdoor Hour challenges · Donna Young: My Opinion of Handbook of Nature Study

Heart of Dakota

Heart of Dakota Publishing

Eden earns a commission

Grades K-12 · Bible, History / social studies, Geography, Science, Language arts, Reading / phonics, Writing, Math, Music · Charlotte Mason · Prep: Open-and-go · About $372 (per family per year) · Christian (explicit)

What this price covers: Economy Package for one level (ages 8 to 10): the guide plus history, geography, Bible and poetry resources. Science, math, language arts and readers are separate purchases.

Try it free: Each guide's page has a free PDF of the introduction and first week of plans; this link is Little Hearts, pick other guides from the Programs menu

What moms say

Pros

  • Very open and go: the guide tells mom exactly what to do each day.
  • Moms love the book choices, and many say their kids came to love reading.
  • Mixes living books, hands-on projects and some textbooks in short daily boxes.

Cons

  • Upper levels can make for long school days with lots of reading.
  • Math is not included, and some find science light, so swapping parts is common.
  • Some moms find the faith content heavier or preachier than they wanted.
  • Buying a full level the first time is costly because of all the books.

Most parent reviews found are from about 2010 to 2017.

From independent reviews: Cathy Duffy Reviews: Heart of Dakota Program (PreK-8) · TheHomeSchoolMom: Heart of Dakota parent reviews · Well-Trained Mind forum: Heart of Dakota pros and cons

Hey Andrew! Teach Me Some Greek! (Greek 'n' Stuff)

Greek 'n' Stuff (Karen Mohs), Moline, IL

Grades 1-12 · Foreign language, Bible · Traditional / textbook · About $41 (per family set (one-time)) · Christian (explicit)

What this price covers: Level 1 full set (of 8 levels): workbook, answer key, quizzes and exams, and flashcards. The workbook alone is $14.95.

What moms say

Pros

  • Moms say a parent with no Greek background can teach it easily.
  • It moves gently, teaching the alphabet a couple of letters at a time, so young kids are not overwhelmed.
  • Older kids can do most of the worktext on their own at about one page a day.
  • Varied activities and a pronunciation CD keep practice fresh, and Bible copywork is included.

Cons

  • The early levels rely mostly on memorizing and drill.
  • Daily flashcard review and oral work need steady parent oversight.
  • Parents without Greek will really want the answer key, which is sold separately.
  • Workbooks are consumable, so each child needs a copy.

All sources are older than about 5 years (2016 and 2017), and both blog posts used review copies through the Homeschool Review Crew.

From independent reviews: Cathy Duffy Reviews: Hey, Andrew! Teach Me Some Greek! · A Fly On My Homeschool Wall: Hey, Andrew! Level 2 review · My (re)Viewpoint: Hey, Andrew! Level 3 review

Hoffman Academy

Hoffman Academy

Grades K-12 · Music · Online / video · Completely free · Secular / neutral

Completely free

Screen-based

Try it free: All the online piano video lessons are free with a free account. Premium adds extra practice tools and printables for a fee.

What moms say

Pros

  • The core video lessons are free, a huge saving over private lessons.
  • Mr. Hoffman's warm, playful style keeps young kids engaged.
  • Teaches ear training and note reading, not just copying.
  • One paid account can cover several children.

Cons

  • Best for young beginners; older kids and teens can find it slow and babyish.
  • There is no live teacher to correct hand position or technique, so a parent needs to supervise practice.
  • After the first unit you really need the paid sheet music or membership, and that cost adds up.

From independent reviews: Well-Trained Mind: Hoffman Academy piano reviews · Well-Trained Mind: Hoffman Academy? · Weird Unsocialized Homeschoolers: Hoffman Academy review

Homeschool in the Woods

Home School in the Woods Publishing

Grades 3-8 · History / social studies, Geography, Art · Unit study · About $150 (per family set (one-time)) · Christian (explicit)

What this price covers: All five Project Passport world history studies as downloads, with a family license for your immediate family. Grades 3 to 8.

Try it free: Each product page has a Sample tab with downloadable sample pages and an audio tour sample. Middle Ages shown here as an example.

What moms say

Pros

  • Kids love the hands-on projects: lapbooks, timelines, newspapers, games and cooking.
  • Supplies are cheap and common, and you can reprint pages for every child.
  • Works across about grades 3 to 8 by choosing activities to fit each child.
  • Many moms say it makes history come alive and is beautifully designed.

Cons

  • Prep is heavy: lots of printing, cutting and assembling, and young kids need help start to finish.
  • It is a supplement, not a full course, so you still need a history spine.
  • The number of files can feel overwhelming at first.
  • Several moms found it too ambitious to finish as many studies in a year as they planned.

From independent reviews: Cathy Duffy Reviews: History Study Time Travelers · Cathy Duffy Reviews: Project Passport · Well-Trained Mind: Homeschool in the Woods History Lapbooks

Homeschool Spanish Academy

Homeschool Spanish Academy (HSA)

Grades K-12 · Foreign language · Online / video · About $720 (per child per year) · Secular / neutral

What this price covers: 60 one-on-one Spanish classes, 25 minutes each ($12 a class). A 30-class package is $480.

Screen-based

What moms say

Pros

  • Moms say the native-speaker teachers are patient and kind, even with shy or very young kids.
  • One-on-one classes give kids real speaking practice that an app or textbook cannot.
  • Scheduling is flexible, and families can choose and rebook favorite teachers.
  • High school levels can count for credit, and siblings can be scheduled together.

Cons

  • One mom liked the teachers but found the course materials disorganized and confusing.
  • A few families reported teachers missing classes or internet trouble cutting lessons short.
  • One parent asked for a refund of unused classes and was turned down under the school's policy.
  • It takes a steady time commitment and is fully online, so it may not suit casual learners.

Mostly Trustpilot chatter; the Modulo page is a secondhand summary, not based on personal use.

From independent reviews: Trustpilot: Homeschool Spanish Academy reviews · Trustpilot: Homeschool Spanish Academy, 1 to 3 star reviews · Modulo: Homeschool Spanish Academy review

Horizons Math (Alpha Omega Publications)

Alpha Omega Publications (AOP)

Eden earns a commission

Grades K-8 · Math · Traditional / textbook · Prep: Open-and-go · About $120 (per subject per year) · Christian (explicit)

What this price covers: 3rd grade math box set: two student books and the teacher's guide, a full year of lessons. Each child needs their own student books.

Try it free: Free Horizons sample pages to download, including Math. Free placement tests are also offered at aop.com/pages/assessment-and-placement-tests.

What moms say

Pros

  • Bright, colorful workbooks keep kids interested.
  • Constant spiral review keeps old skills fresh.
  • It runs ahead of grade level, so kids often test well or move into school easily.
  • Lessons are open-and-go for kids who like workbooks.

Cons

  • New concepts get thin explanation, especially in the upper levels.
  • It moves fast and jumps between topics, which frustrates some kids.
  • Because it is advanced, many families place a level below grade.
  • Daily pages can feel long and worksheet heavy.

The Homeschool Reviews page was seen in search results but returned not found when opened.

From independent reviews: Cathy Duffy Reviews: Horizons Math · Homeschool Reviews: Horizons Mathematics parent reviews · Well-Trained Mind forum: Horizons math

Jacobs' Elementary Algebra / Geometry

Master Books

Eden earns a commission

Grades 9-12 · Math · Traditional / textbook · About $132 (per subject per year) · Christian (explicit)

What this price covers: Elementary Algebra pack for one year (1 credit): student text and teacher guide. Listed $131.98; special price $105.58.

Try it free: Free A Look Inside sample PDF of the Algebra book, plus a free placement test PDF on the same page.

What moms say

Pros

  • Clear, friendly explanations with cartoons and puzzles help kids who fear abstract math.
  • Students can read and learn much of it on their own.
  • It explains why the math works, not just how.
  • Optional DVD lessons help kids who need a teacher.

Cons

  • Daily assignments can be long.
  • Answers are split between books, so you need the teacher guide or solutions manual.
  • Geometry proofs are hard to grade because the key shows only one answer.
  • Full support with guides and DVDs adds up in cost.

From independent reviews: Cathy Duffy Reviews: Jacobs' Elementary Algebra · Well-Trained Mind forum: Finishing Jacobs Geometry, tough year · The Old Schoolhouse: Jacobs Elementary Algebra review

Khan Academy

Khan Academy (501(c)(3) nonprofit)

Grades K-12 · Math, Science, Language arts, History / social studies, Life skills · Online / video · Completely free · Secular / neutral

Completely free

Screen-based

Try it free: The whole thing is free

What moms say

Pros

  • Completely free.
  • Kids can work at their own pace and test out of what they already know.
  • Computer grading and progress tracking save the parent time.
  • Great as a second explanation when a child is stuck, and many kids like the points and badges.

Cons

  • Not enough practice or review for many kids to remember what they learned, especially younger ones.
  • No pacing guide, so the parent has to decide how much to do each day.
  • Works best for self-motivated kids and tends to fade out for others.
  • Most moms use it as a supplement, not a full curriculum, and it is secular.

The forum threads are about 2011 to 2017 and may not reflect Khan's current features. Most feedback is about math.

From independent reviews: Cathy Duffy Reviews: Khan Academy Math Grades K-8 · Well-Trained Mind forum: Has anyone used Khan Academy as their primary math program? · How Do I Homeschool: Is Khan Academy Good for Homeschooling Curriculum?

Kolbe Academy

Kolbe Academy

Grades K-12 · Bible, Language arts, Reading / phonics, Writing, Math, Science, History / social studies, Foreign language, Logic, Art, Music · Classical · Christian (explicit)

Try it free: Free sample course plans for elementary, junior high and high school. Kolbe also offers a free one-week kindergarten preview download (email required).

What moms say

Pros

  • Parents say Kolbe is flexible and lets you swap in other books or co-op classes.
  • Advisors help adjust plans, and the program keeps official records and transcripts.
  • It suits strong readers who thrive on a rich, classic reading list.
  • Enrollment for the book-based program costs far less than full online classes.

Cons

  • Upper grades are very demanding, with heavy reading and writing loads.
  • Weekly plans are less neatly laid out day by day than some programs, so mom does more planning.
  • Some families report slow book orders and slow replies from staff.
  • Online classes add a lot of cost if you go beyond the book-based option.

No Cathy Duffy review of the full program was found, and Reddit could not be reached. Evidence is mostly older Well-Trained Mind forum threads.

From independent reviews: Well-Trained Mind forum: Kolbe or Seton · Well-Trained Mind forum: Tell me about Kolbe Academy please · Well-Trained Mind forum: Kolbe Academy online

Layers of Learning

Layers of Learning

Grades 1-12 · History / social studies, Geography, Science, Art, Writing · Unit study · About $180 (per family set (one-time)) · Secular / neutral

What this price covers: Year One PDF bundle: Ancient History, Earth & Space, People & Planet and Art Beginnings, written to teach all ages together. The paperback bundle is $279.96.

Try it free: Free sample lessons on the site in history, geography, science and the arts. The home page also offers four free unit samples by email signup.

What moms say

Pros

  • Very flexible: you pick which units and activities to use and skip the rest.
  • The whole family can study the same topic together at different levels.
  • Lots of hands-on activities and experiments that younger kids enjoy.
  • Book lists are sorted by age range, and you can buy single units as PDFs.

Cons

  • It is more of an idea bank than a schedule, so the parent does the planning.
  • Instructions for high schoolers are vague, which is hard for busy moms of several grades.
  • Many activities need unusual supplies, and library books are not available for every topic.
  • Some families dislike being tied to its fixed four-year history cycle.

Forum threads could not be opened directly; forum themes come from search summaries.

From independent reviews: Cathy Duffy Reviews: Layers of Learning · Well-Trained Mind: Pros and cons on Layers of Learning? · Well-Trained Mind: Has anyone used Layers of Learning?

Learning Language Arts Through Literature

Common Sense Press

Eden earns a commission

Grades 1-12 · Language arts, Reading / phonics, Writing · Literature-based · Prep: Open-and-go · About $56 (per subject per year) · Christian-friendly

What this price covers: 5th grade (the Purple Book): student book $22.00 plus teacher book $34.00. Other grades cost different amounts.

Try it free: Free sample lessons from every level. Free skills assessments for placement too.

What moms say

Pros

  • It covers grammar, spelling, writing and reading in one book built around real literature.
  • Lessons are gentle and easy to follow.
  • Skills are tied to what the child is reading, which some kids enjoy.
  • It is a good fit for a mom who wants one simple all-in-one language arts plan.

Cons

  • Many moms find it light, especially on grammar and writing, and add more.
  • There is little review of past skills.
  • The book studies can feel disconnected from the rest of the lessons.
  • The reading can be too easy for strong readers.

From independent reviews: Well-Trained Mind forum: LLATL, is it too light? · Well-Trained Mind forum: Is this a complete language arts program? · Cathy Duffy Reviews: Learning Language Arts through Literature

Learning Without Tears (Handwriting Without Tears)

Learning Without Tears

Eden earns a commission

Grades K-6 · Writing · Traditional / textbook · About $14 (per child per year) · Secular / neutral

What this price covers: One grade 1 handwriting student book (My Printing Book); the Teacher's Guide is $49.95 extra. Price not confirmed on the publisher's page.

Try it free: Sample pages for student books and teacher guides, Pre-K to grade 5. Free activities also at lwtears.com/resources/favorite-activities-and-downloads.

What moms say

Pros

  • Lessons are short, often 15 minutes or less.
  • Hands-on pieces like wooden letter shapes and chalk slates help little hands, and therapists trust it.
  • Moms say it helps with letter reversals and works well for struggling or dysgraphic kids.
  • The print books are simple to teach and affordable.

Cons

  • The upright cursive looks plain or odd to many moms, and some switch programs for cursive.
  • The special two-line paper does not match regular school paper.
  • The add-on kits and manipulatives get expensive.
  • Some word and sentence examples do not line up with phonics a child is learning.

From independent reviews: Well-Trained Mind forum: Is there a program like Handwriting Without Tears but prettier? · Well-Trained Mind forum: Handwriting Without Tears, transitioning to cursive or different program? · School Time Snippets: What We Liked and Disliked About Handwriting Without Tears

Life of Fred

Polka Dot Publishing

Eden earns a commission

Grades 1-12 · Math, Language arts, Science · Literature-based · About $19 (per family set (one-time)) · Christian-friendly

What this price covers: One book (Apples, the first of 10 early elementary books). The books are reusable.

What moms say

Pros

  • The silly story format makes math fun, even for kids who dread it.
  • Kids can read it on their own with little parent time.
  • It explains why math works instead of just teaching steps.
  • The books are cheap and reusable for siblings.

Cons

  • There is very little practice, so most families add a second program or extra worksheets.
  • Many moms say it works best as a supplement, not as the only math.
  • The rambling side stories and quirky humor annoy some kids and parents.
  • Some topics are skipped or not fully explained.

From independent reviews: Cathy Duffy Reviews: Life of Fred Math, Elementary · Well-Trained Mind forum: Life of Fred as a stand alone · How Do I Homeschool: Life of Fred Review

LIFEPAC

Alpha Omega Publications (AOP)

Eden earns a commission

Grades K-12 · Bible, Language arts, Math, Science, History / social studies · Traditional / textbook · About $468 (per child per year) · Christian (explicit)

What this price covers: Grade 3 five-subject set: a full school year, with 10 worktexts per subject plus teacher's guides. Grades 2 to 12 are $468.00 each; K and grade 1 differ.

Try it free: Free LIFEPAC placement tests to download for Bible, history, language arts, math and science

What moms say

Pros

  • Simple, straightforward workbooks: read, then answer questions.
  • Works well for self-motivated older kids who like to work on their own.
  • Small booklets give kids a sense of progress, and high school language arts is well liked.

Cons

  • Moms often call it average or thin, and many add more, especially for math.
  • Can feel slow and dry, with little teaching beyond the text.
  • Some content is dated, and kids still need a parent checking in, not total independence.

Evidence is mostly older forum posts; reviews are split.

From independent reviews: Cathy Duffy Reviews: Alpha Omega LIFEPACs · Well-Trained Mind forum: Alpha Omega LifePacs experience? · Well-Trained Mind forum: Alpha Omega Life Pacs (high school)

Lightning Literature & Composition (Hewitt)

Hewitt Learning (publishing arm of Ceiba Connections, a 501(c)3)

Grades K-12 · Language arts, Writing, Reading / phonics · Literature-based · About $100 (per subject per year) · Christian-friendly

What this price covers: Grade 4 set: teacher's guide and student workbook; the pack with the reading books is $209.79. Price not confirmed on the publisher's page.

Try it free: Free catalogs and sample pages for the Lightning Lit levels.

What moms say

Pros

  • Built around real, classic books and picture books instead of short excerpts.
  • Teacher guides have daily plans, so it is close to open and go.
  • Covers reading, literary discussion, grammar and composition in one place, and the color workbooks appeal to kids.
  • High school courses are one semester each, which makes scheduling flexible.

Cons

  • The early levels need a lot of parent time; workbooks are read aloud and the parent needs to know the books to lead discussion.
  • Some levels run hard for the grade, so some families use them a year later.
  • You still need separate phonics, spelling and handwriting.
  • Book packages add to the cost, and some levels require library books.

Most mom reviews found were Homeschool Review Crew posts written with a free copy (2012 to 2019); few critical independent reviews turned up.

From independent reviews: Cathy Duffy Reviews: Lightning Literature and Composition Grades 1-6 · Well-Trained Mind forum: Your thoughts of Hewitt's Lightning Literature · The Curriculum Choice: Lightning Literature review

Master Books

Master Books (New Leaf Publishing Group, LLC)

Eden earns a commission

Grades K-12 · Language arts, Math, Science, History / social studies · Charlotte Mason · Prep: Open-and-go · About $243 (per child per year) · Christian (explicit)

What this price covers: Grade 3 Basic 4 Subject Set: teacher and student materials for 36 weeks of math, language arts, science and history. It has no separate Bible course.

Try it free: Free placement tests for math and language arts; no general samples page found

What moms say

Pros

  • Open and go, with many courses as one all-in-one book.
  • Gentle, story-rich lessons; America's Story and Language Lessons are favorites.
  • Affordable and quick to teach, which suits busy moms and reluctant learners.

Cons

  • Many moms find it light, with not enough practice in math and spelling.
  • Some courses jump around, and a few answer keys have errors.
  • Quality varies a lot from course to course, so check samples first.

Cathy Duffy covers single courses; overall themes come mostly from parent reviews and forums.

From independent reviews: TheHomeSchoolMom: Master Books parent reviews · Well-Trained Mind forum: Masterbooks? Too light? · Cathy Duffy Reviews: Consumer Math (Master Books)

Math Mammoth (Light Blue Series)

Math Mammoth (Maria Miller)

Eden earns a commission

Grades K-8 · Math · Traditional / textbook · Prep: Open-and-go · About $43 (per family set (one-time)) · Secular / neutral

What this price covers: Grade 3 Complete download: two worktexts, answer keys, tests and reviews. You may print copies for the children you teach; lesson plans are $9.95 extra.

Try it free: Free bundle of 400+ sample worksheets plus free placement tests

What moms say

Pros

  • Very affordable, especially the PDF version.
  • Teaches the why behind the math, with strong mental math.
  • Free placement tests and little prep needed.

Cons

  • Plain, text-heavy pages that some kids find long or dry.
  • Not self-teaching for young kids; mom still needs to explain.
  • Occasional errors in the answer key.
  • The main series ends at grade 7.

From independent reviews: Cathy Duffy Reviews: Math Mammoth Light Blue Series · TheHomeSchoolMom: Math Mammoth reviews · Homeschool Reviews: Math Mammoth

Math with Confidence (Kate Snow)

Well-Trained Mind Press

Eden earns a commission

Grades K-6 · Math · Traditional / textbook · Prep: Open-and-go · About $64 (per subject per year) · Secular / neutral

What this price covers: First grade, print: instructor guide $39.95 plus student workbook $23.95, for one year. Grades 3 to 6 need two workbooks, so they cost more.

Try it free: Free sample PDFs for each grade. Open a grade's book page and click the sample link under the cover picture.

What moms say

Pros

  • Moms say the lessons are short, playful and full of games, so young kids enjoy math time.
  • The scripted teacher guide makes it easy for a parent who is nervous about teaching math.
  • It builds real understanding with hands-on work while still adding steady review.
  • It costs less than most programs and uses everyday items you can reuse for several grades.

Cons

  • It needs a parent at the table for every lesson, so it is not independent work.
  • There is some prep, like reading ahead and printing, cutting and laminating game pieces.
  • The early grades call for a long list of manipulatives you have to gather or buy.
  • Lessons get longer and less predictable from third grade on.

Most detailed feedback is from blogs and Cathy Duffy; Reddit sentiment seen only as aggregated snippets, and it is mostly positive.

From independent reviews: Cathy Duffy Reviews: Math with Confidence · Teacher Tutor Mom: Math with Confidence Curriculum Review · Well-Trained Mind forum: Kate Snow math

Math-U-See

Demme Learning

Eden earns a commission

Grades K-12 · Math · Traditional / textbook · About $220 (per child per year) · Christian-friendly

What this price covers: One level (Gamma, multiplication): instruction manual with solutions, student workbook, tests booklet, block kit and a one-year Essential Subscription. Levels go by skill, not grade.

Try it free: Free online placement tool (short yes/no questions) to find your child's starting level

What moms say

Pros

  • Hands-on blocks help kids see and understand math.
  • Short video lessons do much of the teaching.
  • Kids move on only when ready, which helps those who struggle or have gaps.

Cons

  • Costly, and the blocks are an extra purchase.
  • Can fall behind grade level, and quick kids may find it slow or boring.
  • The workbook has little instruction, so you rely on the videos.
  • Some moms find the upper levels weaker.

From independent reviews: Cathy Duffy Reviews: Math-U-See · TheHomeSchoolMom: Math-U-See reviews · Homeschool Reviews: Math-U-See Elementary

Mathematical Reasoning (The Critical Thinking Co.)

The Critical Thinking Co.

Eden earns a commission

Grades K-6 · Math · Traditional / textbook · About $41 (per child per year) · Secular / neutral

What this price covers: Level B (grade 1). Price is a retailer's sale price; the list price is not shown.

Try it free: Free printable sample pages for every book. Click View Sample Pages on each product page.

What moms say

Pros

  • Colorful pages with puzzles make kids think instead of just doing drills.
  • It is low cost, with no teacher manual to buy.
  • Spiral review keeps skills fresh, and it works as a supplement or a light core.

Cons

  • Teaching notes are very brief, so many moms say it is not enough to stand alone.
  • It is not hand-holding, so a parent often has to explain.
  • The challenging problems can frustrate older kids who struggle with math.
  • The early books lack answer keys.

Little forum discussion found; most reviews are blog or review-program posts.

From independent reviews: Cathy Duffy Reviews: Mathematical Reasoning · Walking by the Way: Mathematical Reasoning review · Rainbow Resource: Mathematical Reasoning Level D

Mathseeds

Blake eLearning / 3P Learning

Grades K-3 · Math · Online / video · About $50 (per family per year) · Secular / neutral

What this price covers: Math-only plan for one year, up to 4 children. Monthly it is $6.99; Reading and Math together is $99.99 a year.

Screen-based

What moms say

Pros

  • Moms say the animations, characters and mini-games make math feel like play, and kids ask to use it.
  • Short lessons and rewards like acorns and hatching pets keep young kids motivated.
  • It needs no prep, and a placement test starts each child at the right lesson.
  • Printable activity pages add written practice, so it can serve as a full program in the early years.

Cons

  • Kids who catch on quickly may find the repetition of easy topics tiresome.
  • Moms say it gets thin past first or second grade, so older kids outgrow it.
  • Lessons must go in order, and topics like multiplication come back only after long gaps.
  • The worksheets need a parent's help, and the voices have British or Australian accents.

Cathy Duffy's review is from 2018; the family posts are 2025 blogs, one by a grandmother using the free trial and one with affiliate links.

From independent reviews: Cathy Duffy Reviews: Mathseeds · Living Life and Learning: Mathseeds review for homeschoolers · Homeschool Preschool: MathSeeds review

Memoria Press

Memoria Press

Eden earns a commission

Grades K-12 · Bible, Language arts, Reading / phonics, Writing, Math, Science, History / social studies, Geography, Foreign language · Classical · About $821 (per child per year) · Christian (explicit)

What this price covers: Third Grade set at sale price (regular $1,143.77): 34-week manual plus math, language arts, Latin, science and more. Read-alouds are extra; an extra student's consumables are $315.53.

Try it free: Each grade's page has free sample PDFs of the lesson manual and books; this link is first grade

What moms say

Pros

  • Complete, day-by-day manuals make planning easy.
  • The Latin program is widely seen as one of the best for homeschoolers.
  • Plain, traditional books with no screens, which many families find calming.

Cons

  • The full schedule is heavy, and many families trim it, especially in the early grades.
  • Mom has to teach actively most days; it is not built for independent work.
  • Full grade packages cost several hundred dollars a year.
  • No built-in group or community, unlike co-op programs.

The forum thread could not be opened (blocked); themes come mostly from independent blogs, some affiliate-supported.

From independent reviews: How Do I Homeschool: Memoria Press Review · Well-Trained Mind Forum: Why not Memoria Press? · Homeschool Fox: Memoria Press curriculum review

Grades 4-12 · Writing · Classical · About $107 (per child per year) · Christian (explicit)

What this price covers: Classical Composition I (Fable, one of several stages): student book, teacher guide and streaming videos. Listed $106.90; seen on sale at $96.22.

What moms say

Pros

  • Moms say it builds strong writing skill step by step, starting with retelling fables before students develop their own ideas.
  • The teacher guide includes answers and a grading rubric, and optional videos show a parent how to present lessons.
  • One co-op teacher found her students gladly writing two to three page essays, one every two weeks.
  • It suits small groups and co-ops, where kids can talk through the stories together.

Cons

  • It is not meant for independent study, so a parent needs to prepare ahead and teach most lessons.
  • It is more challenging than many writing programs, and the classical terms can feel intimidating at first.
  • Moms say much of the work is not especially fun, and the second level stretched one sixth grader.
  • The teacher guide does not say how long each step takes, so the optional lesson plans help with pacing.

Sources are older than about 5 years (2016 to about 2020), and the Mama Smiles post used a free review copy.

From independent reviews: Cathy Duffy Reviews: Classical Composition · The Curriculum Choice: Review of Classical Composition by Memoria Press · Mama Smiles: Memoria Press Classical Composition review

Memoria Press Online Academy

Memoria Academy (extension of Memoria Press and Highlands Latin School)

Grades 3-12 · Bible, Language arts, Writing, Math, Science, History / social studies, Geography, Art, Foreign language, Logic · Classical · Christian (explicit)

Screen-based

Grades 2-12 · Language arts, Writing, Reading / phonics · Classical · About $244 (per subject per year) · Secular / neutral

What this price covers: Level 1 complete homeschool package, listed from $244.00 to $488.00 (the publisher's page doesn't show what each end includes).

Try it free: Free sample pages PDF for Grammar Island (Level 1). Other levels have sample PDFs too.

What moms say

Pros

  • Kids and moms love the grammar, and many say it finally makes sense.
  • The poetry and vocabulary books are often called the best part.
  • The playful, story-like books draw kids in, especially bright kids who love words.
  • Read-aloud audio and teacher comments on sample papers save the parent time.

Cons

  • It is expensive once you buy all the books in a level.
  • The writing books feel dull or stiff to some families.
  • The grammar repeats a lot from level to level and some say it stays basic.
  • The whimsical style is too childish for some older kids, and it does not click for every family.

The 'expensive' point is a common forum theme but was not confirmed against current prices.

From independent reviews: Well-Trained Mind forum: Anyone use Michael Clay Thompson language arts and NOT like it? · Well-Trained Mind forum: So, who hasn't liked MCT? Why? · Cathy Duffy Reviews: Michael Clay Thompson Language Arts

Miquon Math

Eden earns a commission

Grades K-3 · Math · Eclectic / mixed · About $17 (per subject per year) · Secular / neutral

What this price covers: One workbook (Orange, Level 1). Six workbooks cover 2 to 3 years; the rods are sold separately. Price from a retailer.

What moms say

Pros

  • Kids discover math for themselves with Cuisenaire rods, which builds a deep feel for numbers.
  • Hands-on, wiggly learners often love it and gain confidence.
  • The workbooks are very inexpensive.

Cons

  • Every page looks different, so the parent has to sit with the child and guide most of it.
  • Parents face a learning curve and really need the teacher notes to know how to use it.
  • Many moms find it too loose to be a full program and use it as a supplement.
  • Kids who are not hands-on learners may not enjoy it.

From independent reviews: Cathy Duffy Reviews: Miquon Math · The Curriculum Choice: Making Math Work with Miquon · The Homeschool Mom: Miquon Math reviews

My Father's World

My Father's World

Eden earns a commission

Grades K-12 · Bible, History / social studies, Science, Art, Music · Eclectic / mixed · About $362 (per child per year) · Christian (explicit)

What this price covers: 3rd grade package: Bible, history, science, art, music and the Teacher's Manual. Math and language arts must be added; the page also shows an unlabeled $482.17.

Try it free: Free sample units to download (Pre-K, Kindergarten, and grades 3 to 8)

What moms say

Pros

  • Easy to use with lessons laid out day by day, so prep is light.
  • Good value, with Bible, history, science, art and music combined in one plan.
  • Hands-on activities and a gentle pace that works well when teaching several kids together.

Cons

  • Many moms find it light, especially science and language arts, and add more.
  • Math and language arts must be bought separately from about 2nd grade.
  • The kindergarten level feels too easy to some, more like preschool.

Many parent reviews are from roughly 2010 to 2015.

From independent reviews: Cathy Duffy Reviews: My Father's World, Grades K-8 · TheHomeSchoolMom: My Father's World parent reviews · Well-Trained Mind forum: Can we talk about My Father's World?

Mystery Science

Mystery Science (Mystery.org), part of Discovery Education

Grades K-5 · Science · Online / video · Prep: Open-and-go · About $199 (per family per year) · Secular / neutral

What this price covers: Homeschool membership, Mystery Science only, with access through June 30, 2027. Science plus Writing is $259.

Screen-based

Try it free: New homeschool families can type an email on the home page and click Get free access for a free trial. One trial per family.

What moms say

Pros

  • Kids love the short, well made videos and hands-on activities.
  • Easy for the parent to teach, and it works well with several kids at once.
  • Uses simple household supplies instead of costly kits.
  • Low cost for a full year compared with boxed science programs.

Cons

  • Light on tests and written work, so it feels more like a supplement than a full course.
  • Many moms feel it is enough only through about 2nd grade; older kids need more science time.
  • You still have to gather supplies, and a printer is a must.
  • It is a yearly subscription built mainly for schools, and access ends unless you renew.

From independent reviews: Cathy Duffy Reviews: Mystery Science · Well-Trained Mind forum: Mystery Science current feedback · Because We Homeschool: Why we love Mystery Science

Nancy Larson Science

Nancy Larson Publishers

Grades K-5 · Science · Traditional / textbook · Prep: Open-and-go · About $460 (per child per year) · Secular / neutral

What this price covers: The Science 1 Complete Program. Other levels cost different amounts: K $420, Science 4 $480, Science 5 $510.

Try it free: One or two free PDF sample lessons for each level, Science K to 5, plus tables of contents and the word wall list.

What moms say

Pros

  • Fully scripted and open and go, with every supply arriving in one box.
  • Kids are engaged and often ask to keep going.
  • Strong focus on science vocabulary, and kids remember what they learned.
  • Short workbook and review pages are a manageable amount of writing.

Cons

  • Expensive; a full grade level runs roughly $280 to $350.
  • Needs a lot of one-on-one parent time and does not stretch well to a big group.
  • Covers many topics each year, which some feel is too broad for young kids.
  • Each level is pitched at a narrow age, so older kids may find it too easy.

Prices are from Cathy Duffy's older review and may have changed.

From independent reviews: Cathy Duffy Reviews: Nancy Larson Science · The Curriculum Choice: Nancy Larson Science review · Well-Trained Mind forum: Nancy Larson Science

Notgrass History

Notgrass History

Eden earns a commission

Grades 1-12 · History / social studies, Geography · Eclectic / mixed · Prep: Open-and-go · About $95 (per subject per year) · Christian (explicit)

What this price covers: One year of U.S. history for grades 1 to 4 (Our Star-Spangled Story): Parts 1 and 2, timeline, answer key and one student workbook. The literature package is separate.

Try it free: Download the first three units of a course free, with workbooks and tests

What moms say

Pros

  • Moms like having history, literature and Bible together in one program.
  • The friendly, story-like writing and pretty books keep kids engaged.
  • Open-and-go daily lessons with little prep, and one set can serve several kids.
  • Real books and primary-source readers add depth.

Cons

  • There is often more material than a family can finish, especially on a 4-day week.
  • Some moms find it light on rigor, more of an overview than a deep study.
  • Not very hands-on, and the map work is simple.
  • The full package with literature is pricey, and big families may need extra textbooks.

Notgrass has several courses. Many forum comments are about the high school courses, which may not match the elementary ones.

From independent reviews: Cathy Duffy Reviews: From Adam to Us (Notgrass) · Well-Trained Mind forum: How rigorous is Notgrass American History? · Homeschool Giveaways: Notgrass History Review

Phonics Pathways

Jossey-Bass (John Wiley & Sons); author Dolores G. Hiskes

Eden earns a commission

Grades K-2 · Reading / phonics · Traditional / textbook · About $35 (per family set (one-time)) · Secular / neutral

What this price covers: One book (10th edition paperback). The e-book is $21.00.

Try it free: Wiley's book page has Read an Excerpt with a free sample PDF and table of contents.

What moms say

Pros

  • One inexpensive book takes a child through all of phonics with no separate teacher manual.
  • It is open and go with almost no prep, and you can adapt it freely because it is not scripted.
  • The large print is easy on young eyes.
  • Many moms say it worked for several of their kids in a row.

Cons

  • Pages look busy and crowded, and some kids feel overwhelmed by them.
  • There is not much practice per concept, so many moms add flashcards or extra readers.
  • It moves slowly and repeats a lot for a child who already reads a little.
  • Some instructions are written to the child, so you have to read and explain them.

Cathy Duffy's page for this book was written by the author, so it was not used as an independent source. Reddit could not be searched from this tool.

From independent reviews: Well-Trained Mind forum: Phonics Pathways? · Well-Trained Mind forum: Phonics Pathways vs. Ordinary Parent's Guide to Reading · Rainbow Resource: Phonics Pathways

Positive Action Bible Curriculum

Positive Action for Christ

Eden earns a commission

Grades K-12 · Bible · Traditional / textbook · About $76 (per child per year) · Christian (explicit)

What this price covers: Grade 3 (Growing with God): teacher's manual $54.95 plus student manual $20.95, 35 weekly lessons.

Try it free: Open any grade's study page and click the Samples tab for free student and teacher manual sample PDFs.

What moms say

Pros

  • Covers preschool through high school, so a family can stay with one program.
  • Daily lessons include memory verses, vocabulary and a character trait each week.
  • Upper grades teach kids to look up verses and study a topic across the Bible.
  • Moms say the school-written books work fine at home, and samples are online.

Cons

  • Some moms feel parts of the workbook are fill-in-the-blank busy work.
  • Heavy verse look-up in upper grades can feel like a chore to some kids.
  • Workbooks are grade-specific, so each child needs their own level.

Thin independent evidence: Cathy Duffy lists it but her review text was not found; most blog reviews are a 2011 free-copy review-crew batch.

From independent reviews: Well-Trained Mind: Bible curriculum recommendations · Through the Calm and Through the Storm: TOS review, Positive Action for Christ · Rainbow Resource: Positive Action for Christ Bible Curriculum

PRIDE Reading Program

PRIDE Reading Program

Grades K-12 · Reading / phonics, Language arts, Writing · Traditional / textbook · Prep: Open-and-go · About $145 (per family set (one-time)) · Secular / neutral

What this price covers: One level kit (Yellow), starting price. Other levels run $94.90 to $159.85.

What moms say

Pros

  • The fully scripted teacher guide lets a parent with no training teach it step by step.
  • Its hands-on Orton-Gillingham approach is built for kids who struggle with reading.
  • Moms say the magnetic foam letter tiles and quick online games keep kids engaged.
  • Each skill is taught, practiced and reinforced, and kids master it before moving on.

Cons

  • Quick learners may find it too repetitive.
  • Lessons often run an hour or longer, and the full program takes two years or more.
  • The parent must teach every lesson, since the workbook depends on parent instruction.
  • Going back to an earlier module in the online guide is clunky.

Apart from Cathy Duffy (2020), both blog reviews were sponsored posts written with free or compensated copies.

From independent reviews: Cathy Duffy Reviews: Pride Reading Program · Homeschool Hideout: PRIDE Reading Program review · How Do I Homeschool: Pride Reading Program review

Primary Arts of Language (Institute for Excellence in Writing)

Institute for Excellence in Writing (IEW)

Eden earns a commission

Grades K-2 · Language arts, Reading / phonics, Writing · Eclectic / mixed · About $179 (per family set (one-time)) · Christian-friendly

What this price covers: Reading and writing Premier Package with printed student books. The Reading package alone is $69; Writing alone is $89.

Try it free: First three weeks of lessons free for each book, student and teacher PDFs.

What moms say

Pros

  • Gentle and playful, with poems, games and file-folder activities kids enjoy.
  • Reading, writing and spelling are tied together in one program.
  • It works well for hands-on kids and kids who need multisensory teaching.
  • Parents get a lot of guidance and teaching help.

Cons

  • It is very teacher intensive, especially the first month.
  • There is a lot of prep, like cutting cards and putting games together.
  • It can look overwhelming at first and is not the simplest to use.
  • Some kids dislike the cutting, pasting and coloring worksheets.

From independent reviews: Cathy Duffy Reviews: Primary Arts of Language, Reading and Writing · Pam Barnhill: How we use and why I love PAL · Well-Trained Mind forum: For those that have used IEW PAL

Reading Horizons At-Home

Reading Horizons

Grades K-12 · Reading / phonics, Language arts · Online / video · About $199 (per child per year) · Secular / neutral

What this price covers: Discovery online software (ages 4 to 9), starting price; the page does not say how long access lasts. Instructor-guided materials start at $399.

Screen-based

What moms say

Pros

  • One mom says her teen worked through it on her own and gained reading speed and spelling in about six weeks.
  • Kids can test out of lessons they already know, and trouble spots come back for review.
  • Moms praise the parent training, and the younger level is colorful with lots of games.
  • The older level is built for struggling readers from about age ten through adulthood.

Cons

  • It moves quickly, which may be too fast for kids with more severe dyslexia.
  • Some families had trouble getting the online program set up at first.
  • Moms list price as a drawback, and one commenter found the word-marking code confusing.
  • One parent reported glitches, thin practice and a sharp jump in difficulty partway through.

Thin: both mom posts are from one blogger whose pages carry affiliate links (the first dates to about 2014), and most Trustpilot reviewers are classroom teachers.

From independent reviews: Homeschooling with Dyslexia: Help for the older struggling reader · Homeschooling with Dyslexia: Comparison of the top 4 Orton-Gillingham programs · Trustpilot: Reading Horizons reviews

Real Science-4-Kids (Gravitas Publications)

Real Science-4-Kids (gravitaspublications.com 301-redirects to rs4k.com)

Grades K-7 · Science · Traditional / textbook · Prep: Open-and-go · About $184 (per child per year) · Secular / neutral

What this price covers: Science Book 1, print trio: textbook, student pages and teacher pages. The textbook alone is $92; the trio plus RS4K Science Academy is $289.

Try it free: FAQ links a free sample page for each of Science Books 1 to 7, plus a reader library demo. The experiments are free to use too.

What moms say

Pros

  • Teaches real science terms and concepts that prepare kids for later science.
  • Bright, visual books and labs that are generally easy and fun to run.
  • Easy for parents to teach and follow, and religiously neutral.
  • Newer editions add quizzes and a final exam with answer keys.

Cons

  • Some moms find it thin; a strong student can finish a book in weeks.
  • Older editions have no worksheets or tests.
  • Lab supplies need planning ahead.
  • Content can be challenging for young kids, so parents need to read aloud and help.

From independent reviews: Cathy Duffy Reviews: Real Science-4-Kids Series · The Homeschool Mom: Real Science-4-Kids reader reviews · The Curriculum Choice: Real Science 4 Kids

Saxon Math

Houghton Mifflin Harcourt (HMH)

Eden earns a commission

Grades K-12 · Math · Traditional / textbook · About $118 (per subject per year) · Secular / neutral

What this price covers: One math level: the Saxon Math 5/4 Homeschool Kit (3rd edition). Price from a retailer (Rainbow Resource), which lists MSRP $323.13.

What moms say

Pros

  • Constant review helps kids remember what they learned.
  • Clear, step by step lessons that are easy for mom to teach.
  • Older kids can work fairly independently.
  • Inexpensive and widely available, including used.

Cons

  • Very repetitive, and many kids find it tedious.
  • Long daily lessons and plain black and white pages.
  • Kids who already struggle can feel overwhelmed by the mix of topics.
  • Hard to skip ahead for kids who learn fast.

Many parent reviews are older (some 2010 or earlier).

From independent reviews: Cathy Duffy Reviews: Saxon Math 5/4 through Calculus · TheHomeSchoolMom: Saxon Math reviews · Homeschool Reviews: Saxon Math 5/4 through 8/7

Science Shepherd

Science Shepherd (Ohana Life Press, LLC)

Grades 1-12 · Science · Online / video · Prep: Open-and-go · About $74 (per subject per year) · Christian (explicit)

What this price covers: Earth Science bundle (video course, workbook and answer key) at its lowest listed price; the page does not say which level or format. Others run up to $142.00.

Screen-based

Try it free: Free course previews with full lesson videos; Introductory Science preview has 6 lessons and workbook pages

What moms say

Pros

  • Open-and-go short daily videos with a matching workbook, about 10 minutes a day.
  • Siblings can share the same videos and use different workbook levels.
  • Kids can work mostly on their own, and parents don't need a science background.
  • The price is reasonable.

Cons

  • Several moms found the elementary level too easy for the older ages it lists.
  • There are few real tests, and little writing in the younger workbook.
  • Kids get little out of the workbook unless they watch the videos closely.
  • Fewer hands-on activities than kit-based programs.

Thin. Most elementary reviews are from a 2016 free-copy review crew, the Homeschool Scientist review used a free copy, and the forum posts are old.

From independent reviews: The Homeschool Scientist: Science Shepherd Review · Well-Trained Mind forum: Anyone thinking of using Science Shepherd's new Introductory Science · The Curriculum Choice: Simple, informative Christian online elementary science program

Science Unlocked

Home Science Tools

Eden earns a commission

Grades K-12 · Science · About $300 (per subject per year) · Secular / neutral

What this price covers: One full-year course (Earth and Space, grades 3 to 7): student workbooks, teacher guides, assessments, schedules and the materials for hands-on investigations.

What moms say

Pros

  • Almost everything for the experiments comes in the box, so there is very little shopping.
  • Strongly hands-on, with full instructions and good thinking questions.
  • Each kit includes a teacher guide, student workbook and schedule, and you can buy one kit or a full-year bundle.
  • Older levels need less parent teaching.

Cons

  • It is expensive, especially the full-year bundles.
  • Some moms feel it is mostly experiments and less of a complete course.
  • The youngest level needs a lot of parent involvement.
  • It is secular and teaches an old earth, which some Christian families mention.

Thin. Few independent mom reviews exist. Most other coverage is from the seller or sponsored bloggers, which were not used. Cathy Duffy's review is from about 2022.

From independent reviews: Cathy Duffy Reviews: Science Unlocked Kits · Well-Trained Mind forum: Boxed Science Curriculum with Experiments (3rd and 5th)

Seton Home Study School

Seton Home Study School (Front Royal, VA)

Grades K-12 · Bible, Language arts, Reading / phonics, Writing, Math, Science, History / social studies, Art, Music · Traditional / textbook · Christian (explicit)

Try it free: Each grade page lets you open sample pages from every book and sample lesson plans as free PDFs. No single samples page; pick your grade.

What moms say

Pros

  • Daily lesson plans are clear and laid out for every day, so there is little planning for mom.
  • Kids can work fairly independently from the plans.
  • Seton handles grading, records and an accredited diploma.
  • Parents can trim parent-graded work and skip practice a child has mastered.

Cons

  • Many moms find the workload heavy, with lots of busywork and long tests to memorize for.
  • High school is hard to finish on time, and some kids burn out.
  • It can feel rigid and workbook driven, with work too easy or too hard for a given child.
  • Support for kids with special needs is limited.

From independent reviews: Well-Trained Mind forum: Seton - Experience, Research, Reviews? · Well-Trained Mind forum: Anyone used Seton Home Study? · TheHomeSchoolMom: Seton Home Study School reviews

Shiller Math

ShillerLearning

Eden earns a commission

Grades K-8 · Math · Montessori · About $400 (per family set (one-time)) · Secular / neutral

What this price covers: Math Kit I (PreK to 3), one-time; the publisher says one kit serves every child in the family. Price not confirmed on the publisher's page.

What moms say

Pros

  • Montessori-style manipulatives and songs suit hands-on and auditory kids.
  • Lessons are scripted, so there is little or no prep.
  • Kids who struggle with writing can answer out loud.
  • Materials are colorful and good quality, and consumable pages can be printed free.

Cons

  • The full kits are expensive compared with most math programs.
  • Some kids need more written practice and drill than it gives.
  • Lessons jump between topics, and the unusual order makes switching programs harder.
  • Some reviewers found the plastic manipulatives flimsy next to real Montessori materials.

Thin independent feedback; several blog reviews were free-product review arrangements, and forum discussion is sparse.

From independent reviews: Cathy Duffy Reviews: ShillerLearning Math · Math Geek Mama: ShillerMath Review (Kit 1) · Erica's Homeschool Ideas: Shiller Math first impressions

Simply Charlotte Mason

Simply Charlotte Mason

Grades K-12 · Bible, Language arts, Math, Science, History / social studies, Geography, Art, Music, Foreign language · Charlotte Mason · Prep: Open-and-go · Christian (explicit)

Try it free: Free sample PDFs of the lesson plan guides

What moms say

Pros

  • Family-style lessons let you teach several ages together, which saves time.
  • Daily guides are clear and open and go for moms new to Charlotte Mason.
  • Uses real living books instead of dry textbooks.
  • Moderate cost, since you can buy only the subjects you need.

Cons

  • Costs add up when you buy every subject separately.
  • History does not cover every key event, so some families add more.
  • Lighter on literature and fewer books per subject than AmblesideOnline.

Thin: few detailed independent reviews surfaced; the main review site may be affiliate-supported, and Cathy Duffy's full review was not opened.

From independent reviews: Homeschool Picks: Simply Charlotte Mason Review · SCM Forum: "[lacks] comprehensive coverage of key events of history" (discussing Cathy Duffy's review) · Homeschool Fox: Review of the Charlotte Mason curriculum

Simply Classical (Memoria Press)

Memoria Press

Eden earns a commission

Grades K-12 · Bible, Language arts, Reading / phonics, Writing, Math, Science, History / social studies, Geography, Music, Foreign language · Classical · Christian (explicit)

Try it free: Free printable readiness assessments for every Simply Classical level, used to pick the right starting level.

What moms say

Pros

  • Built for kids with learning struggles, with small, gentle steps.
  • Readiness checklists help moms pick the right starting level.
  • Lower levels use hands-on, sensory and movement activities kids enjoy.
  • Scripted teacher guides tell mom exactly what to do each day.

Cons

  • It needs a lot of one-on-one teaching time from mom every day.
  • Early levels call for many supplies, some unusual, that you must gather.
  • It gives only general tips, not help for a specific diagnosis like autism or hearing loss.
  • Some parents find it assumes steady, step-by-step progress and end up swapping in other math or writing programs.

Independent parent feedback is limited; the cons rely mainly on Cathy Duffy plus a few forum comments.

From independent reviews: Cathy Duffy Reviews: Memoria Press Simply Classical Core Curriculum · Well-Trained Mind forum: Seeking secular alternative to Memoria Press Simply Classical

Grades K-8 · Math · Traditional / textbook · About $169 (per child per year) · Secular / neutral

What this price covers: Grade 3 math set with Home Instructor's Guides. The publisher says its bundles include all student and educator material for a school year.

Try it free: Free placement tests for Dimensions Math KA through 5B; Look Inside samples on each book page

What moms say

Pros

  • Moves from hands-on to pictures to numbers, which builds real understanding.
  • Strong, advanced content with extra challenge problems for bright kids.
  • Optional videos can carry some of the teaching.

Cons

  • Needs a lot of mom's time and the teacher's guide, especially in the early grades.
  • Runs ahead of most programs, so switching in mid-way is hard.
  • Many separate books plus your own manipulatives add up in cost.
  • Best for average to advanced kids; struggling kids may find it too fast.

Many blog reviews are from a 2019 review program with free copies; fewer long-term independent mom reviews of Dimensions specifically.

From independent reviews: Cathy Duffy Reviews: Dimensions Math (grades PK-5) · Cathy Duffy Reviews: Dimensions Math Levels 6-8 · Sheena Loves Sunsets: Dimensions Singapore Math Review

Grades 1-3 · Foreign language, Music · Classical · About $107 (per family set (one-time)) · Christian-friendly

What this price covers: The Song School Greek program bundle. Price, contents and stock not confirmed on the publisher's page.

What moms say

Pros

  • Catchy songs on the audio help young kids remember new words and pronunciation.
  • Each week brings only a few new words, plus games and activities to practice them.
  • Families who used Song School Latin will find the same familiar format.
  • Exercises are thorough but fun, mixing written work, audio, matching cards and games.

Cons

  • One mom with no Greek background found it hard going until she bought the Teacher's Edition.
  • Progress can feel slow, and that family had only just learned the alphabet when she wrote.
  • It mixes Koine and modern Greek and stresses everyday words, which may not match every family's goals.
  • It gives a foundation only, so kids will need another Greek course afterward.

Thin: one mom blog post (first written 2012) and one bookseller staff review; forum threads were blocked.

From independent reviews: AtoZMom: Review of Song School Greek · Exodus Books: Greek for Children series review (covers Song School Greek)

Song School Latin / Latin for Children (Classical Academic Press)

Classical Academic Press

Eden earns a commission

Grades K-6 · Foreign language · Classical · About $30 (per subject per year) · Christian-friendly

What this price covers: Song School Latin Book 1 student edition only.

Try it free: Free guided page tour of Song School Latin Book 1. A Latin for Children Primer A tour is on the same site.

What moms say

Pros

  • Song School Latin is a gentle, fun start for young kids, and the songs really help them remember words.
  • The parent does not need to know any Latin; videos do much of the teaching.
  • Latin for Children is thorough but broken into small chunks with lots of review, and it leads smoothly into later Latin.
  • Little or no lesson prep for the parent.

Cons

  • Buying every piece (books, videos, chant CDs, activity books) gets expensive.
  • Chanting still needs a parent nearby to coach and correct.
  • The songs get stuck in everyone's head, which some families find annoying.
  • Latin for Children is not a good fit for kids under about 8, and the later primers get noticeably harder.

From independent reviews: Cathy Duffy Reviews: Latin for Children · Cathy Duffy Reviews: Song School Latin · Hip Homeschool Moms: Song School Latin user reviews

Song School Spanish (Classical Academic Press)

Classical Academic Press

Eden earns a commission

Grades 2-3 · Foreign language · Classical · Christian-friendly

Try it free: Free guided page tour of Song School Spanish Book 2. No Book 1 tour found.

What moms say

Pros

  • A fun, gentle first taste of Spanish for kids about 5 to 8, with catchy songs.
  • Not too cutesy, so it holds young kids' attention without feeling babyish.
  • Short lessons with songs, games and flashcards, and the parent does not need to speak Spanish.

Cons

  • Very light on grammar and speaking, so it is a starter, not a full Spanish program.
  • It needs a parent sitting with the child; it is not independent.
  • Some families found it took longer than a year, or added another program for more interaction.

Thin independent evidence. Most reviews are from 2013 review-crew posts written with a free copy.

From independent reviews: Cathy Duffy Reviews: Song School Spanish · Teach Beside Me: Song School Spanish review · Hip Homeschool Moms: Song School Spanish user review

Sonlight

Sonlight Curriculum, Ltd.

Grades K-12 · Bible, History / social studies, Language arts, Reading / phonics, Writing, Math, Science · Literature-based · About $940 (per child per year) · Christian (explicit)

What this price covers: Package C (3rd grade): all subjects for one school year with a 36-week Instructor's Guide, after the built-in 20% bundle discount. Other grades cost different amounts.

Try it free: Free PDF of the first three weeks of any Instructor's Guide, preschool through high school

What moms say

Pros

  • Kids love the read-aloud books and real stories, and many families say it builds a love of reading.
  • The daily guide is all planned out, so there is very little prep for mom.
  • History and literature are tied together through biographies and great books.

Cons

  • It is expensive, and some moms feel the price is more than the value.
  • There is a lot of reading aloud, which can wear mom out and feel like too much to finish.
  • Some book picks feel too mature or heavy for young kids, so moms pre-read or skip.
  • Language arts feels dry to some families, and it has no phonics program of its own.

Many parent reviews date from about 2011 to 2014; Sonlight has revised several courses since.

From independent reviews: Cathy Duffy Reviews: Sonlight Curriculum · TheHomeSchoolMom: Sonlight parent reviews · Well-Trained Mind forum: Why the dislike for Sonlight?

Spanish for You!

Spanish for You!

Grades 3-8 · Foreign language · Eclectic / mixed · About $75 (per family set (one-time)) · Secular / neutral

What this price covers: One themed package (24 to 30 weekly lessons) for grades 3 to 8 together: reusable textbook, workbook PDF and audio.

Try it free: Free week 3 samples from one course: book pages, lesson guide, worksheets and audio. Free mini lessons too.

What moms say

Pros

  • Audio reads everything aloud, so the parent does not need to know Spanish.
  • Catchy songs, games and flashcard ideas keep kids engaged.
  • Affordable, and one theme can be used with several ages (grades 3 to 8) at once.

Cons

  • Some families found it moves slowly and stays on one topic a long time.
  • Not grammar heavy, so it may not prepare kids well for high school Spanish on its own.
  • Worksheet titles are all in Spanish, which confused some families.

Thin independent evidence. Most reviews found are from 2013 review-crew posts; few forum discussions turned up.

From independent reviews: Cathy Duffy Reviews: Spanish for You! · Teach Beside Me: Spanish for You curriculum review · Tot Play: Independent review of Spanish for You Mi Vida

Spelling You See

Demme Learning

Eden earns a commission

Grades K-8 · Language arts, Reading / phonics · Charlotte Mason · About $65 (per subject per year) · Christian-friendly

What this price covers: One level (Level C, Wild Tales): 36 lessons with a one-year Basic Subscription; levels go by skill, not grade. Price and contents not confirmed on the publisher's page.

Try it free: Free placement tool and placement paragraphs to find the right level. No free lesson sample found.

What moms say

Pros

  • No word lists or weekly tests, which many families find a relief.
  • Short daily lessons of about 15 to 20 minutes using copywork, color marking of letter chunks, and dictation.
  • Some kids who hated spelling do it without fuss.
  • Moms who stick with it report steady gains over a few levels.

Cons

  • Results vary; some moms saw little improvement after months.
  • There is little built-in review, so words may not come back again.
  • Some kids find the daily copying boring.
  • You need both the handbook and a student pack every level, which adds up.

Many blog reviews came from sponsored review crews, so forum posts were weighted more.

From independent reviews: Well-Trained Mind forum: All About Spelling or Spelling You See? · Well-Trained Mind forum: Reviews on Spelling You See? · Cathy Duffy Reviews: Spelling You See

SQUILT Music Appreciation

SQUILT Music Appreciation (Mary Prather)

Grades K-8 · Music · Eclectic / mixed · Prep: Open-and-go · About $280 (per family set (one-time)) · Christian-friendly

What this price covers: The Complete bundle (digital PDF volumes). Some pieces are sold separately.

Try it free: Sample pack with one recorded live lesson and one do-it-yourself PDF lesson. The site calls it low-cost and the price was not shown, so it may not be free.

What moms say

Pros

  • Mom needs no music background; lessons are scripted and open-and-go.
  • Very affordable, with one-time PDF volumes.
  • One lesson works for several ages at once.
  • Short, relaxed listening lessons that fit easily into a week.

Cons

  • Geared to younger kids; some moms felt their children aged out by late elementary.
  • It teaches listening only, not music theory, reading notes or an instrument.
  • Some links inside the older PDFs no longer work.
  • Live classes run at set times and basic recordings expire.

Thin independent evidence: no Cathy Duffy review found, forum mentions are brief, and most blog reviews are affiliate or free-copy posts.

From independent reviews: Well-Trained Mind: Music, what do you use? · Every Bed of Roses: SQUILT review · Humility and Doxology: SQUILT review

Structure and Style for Students (Institute for Excellence in Writing)

Institute for Excellence in Writing (IEW)

Eden earns a commission

Grades 3-12 · Writing · Online / video · About $169 (per subject per year) · Christian-friendly

What this price covers: Year 1 Level A Basic writing course (grades 3 to 5) for one student: teacher's manual, student packet and binder, and 24 video lessons. It runs 24 weeks.

Screen-based

Try it free: Free first 3 weeks of Structure and Style for Students online (Levels A, B and C)

What moms say

Pros

  • Kids enjoy Andrew Pudewa's funny, lively video teaching.
  • Key-word outlines and checklists give reluctant writers a clear, step-by-step way to start.
  • Lesson plans are laid out for you, and the video license never expires, so siblings only need a new student packet.
  • Works well with two or more kids, or in a co-op class.

Cons

  • Early writing can sound forced and formulaic until the style becomes natural.
  • It is mostly structured writing, with little free creative writing.
  • Grammar and spelling are light, so many families add Fix It! Grammar.
  • It costs a lot up front, and a parent still has to edit every paper.

The Monkey and Mom post is affiliate-supported. Fewer independent mom reviews of the cons turned up than for the other programs.

From independent reviews: Cathy Duffy Reviews: Structure and Style for Students · Cathy Duffy Reviews: Teaching Writing: Structure and Style seminar · Monkey and Mom: IEW writing programs, the truth about IEW

Teach Your Child to Read in 100 Easy Lessons

Simon & Schuster (authors Siegfried Engelmann, Phyllis Haddox, Elaine Bruner)

Eden earns a commission

Grades K-1 · Reading / phonics · Traditional / textbook · About $30 (per family set (one-time)) · Secular / neutral

What this price covers: One book (revised second edition paperback), a one-time purchase. Price from a retailer.

Try it free: Publisher page has a Read an Excerpt section starting at Lesson 1.

What moms say

Pros

  • It is cheap, and everything you need is in one book.
  • The scripted lessons take about 15 to 20 minutes and need no prep.
  • Many moms report fast results, with some kids reading well above grade level by the end.
  • It works well for a young child who has never been taught to read.

Cons

  • Moms tend to love it or hate it; the script feels stiff and inflexible to many.
  • The special letter shapes can confuse kids, and some struggle to switch to normal print around lesson 70.
  • Phonics coverage is incomplete, so many moms follow it with another program.
  • It is plain black and white and can feel dry to a child who likes color.

From independent reviews: Well-Trained Mind forum: Can we talk about 100 EZ lessons? · Well-Trained Mind forum: Where did you go after 100 Easy Lessons? · Cathy Duffy Reviews: Teach Your Child to Read in 100 Easy Lessons

Teaching Textbooks

Teaching Textbooks, LLC

Grades 3-12 · Math · Online / video · Prep: Open-and-go · About $49 (per child per year) · Secular / neutral

What this price covers: Math 3 app for one student for 12 months, without printed books. Each extra child is another $48.95; a Family Plan for 4 to 8 students is $239.95.

Screen-based

Try it free: Free trial of the first 15 lessons of any level, no credit card and no time limit

What moms say

Pros

  • Kids can work on their own, and the computer grades the work.
  • Clear, friendly explanations that help math-anxious kids.
  • Lots of review so concepts stick.

Cons

  • Runs about a level behind, so many kids start one level up.
  • Repetitive, with many review lessons before new material.
  • Advanced or STEM-minded kids may need more challenge or extra fact drill.
  • Costs more per level than many book-based programs.

From independent reviews: Cathy Duffy Reviews: Teaching Textbooks Math 3 through PreCalculus · TheHomeSchoolMom: Teaching Textbooks reviews · Homeschool Reviews: Teaching Textbooks Elementary

Grades 7-8 · Logic · Classical · About $147 (per child per year) · Christian-friendly

What this price covers: The full program: student edition, teacher's edition and streaming video. Price and contents not confirmed on the product page.

What moms say

Pros

  • Humor, photos and Socrates skits make learning logical fallacies fun.
  • Examples from ads, politics and pop culture help teens spot bad reasoning in everyday life.
  • The teacher's edition has answers, quizzes and tests, and several schedule options are offered.
  • One mom strongly recommends the optional DVDs, where teachers and students talk through each fallacy.

Cons

  • It can be wordy, and new terms confuse some students, so a parent may need to work alongside.
  • One family found each day took one to two hours, and some writing and research are required.
  • It is more structured and writing based than the gentler Fallacy Detective.
  • Cathy Duffy found it fits high school, with only some junior high students ready for it.

Both blog reviews used free copies, and Cathy Duffy's review was last edited in 2016.

From independent reviews: Cathy Duffy Reviews: The Art of Argument, The Argument Builder and The Discovery of Deduction · The Curriculum Choice: Art of the Argument · Hip Homeschool Moms: Review of The Art of Argument

Grades 8-9 · Logic · Classical · About $170 (per child per year) · Christian-friendly

What this price covers: The Discovery of Deduction program. Price and contents not confirmed on the publisher's page.

What moms say

Pros

  • Socratic dialogues and skits read aloud make formal logic engaging.
  • One mom found it just hard enough to make her daughter think, without being too easy.
  • It connects formal logic to real-life examples and to reading, research and writing.
  • The teacher's edition has the student pages with answers already filled in.

Cons

  • It needs much more parent discussion and oversight than a hands-off workbook.
  • Cathy Duffy thinks high schoolers are more likely to use it than eighth graders.
  • Families are advised to finish The Art of Argument first.
  • Kids who dislike workbooks may see it as one more workbook.

Both blog reviews were free-copy posts, one from 2013, and Cathy Duffy's review was last edited in 2016.

From independent reviews: Cathy Duffy Reviews: The Art of Argument, The Argument Builder and The Discovery of Deduction · The Curriculum Choice: The Discovery of Deduction · Tillieisms: Schoolhouse Review Crew, The Discovery of Deduction

The Fallacy Detective

Christian Logic (brand); site copyright Nathaniel Bluedorn and Hans Bluedorn

Grades 7-12 · Logic · Traditional / textbook · About $32 (per family set (one-time)) · Christian (explicit)

What this price covers: One paperback book (264 pages), which includes The Fallacy Detective Game. The ebook is $9.99.

What moms say

Pros

  • Cartoons, comic strips and humor make it one of the friendliest ways into logic.
  • Parents need no logic training to lead it, and the answers are in the back.
  • Kids start spotting faulty reasoning in ads, speeches and the news.
  • Short lessons work alone or alongside a formal logic course, and a game is included.

Cons

  • It is not a formal logic course, so families wanting traditional logic will need more.
  • It shines with discussion, so Cathy Duffy suggests at least two students working together.
  • Kids may read it straight through quickly instead of doing one lesson a week.

Cathy Duffy's review was last edited in 2016, and the Lille Punkin post used a free copy.

From independent reviews: Cathy Duffy Reviews: The Fallacy Detective · TheHomeSchoolMom: Teaching critical thinking with The Fallacy Detective · Lille Punkin: The Fallacy Detective review

The Good and the Beautiful

The Good and the Beautiful (Jenny Phillips)

Grades K-12 · Language arts, Reading / phonics, Writing, Math, Science, History / social studies · Eclectic / mixed · Prep: Open-and-go · About $148 (per child per year) · Christian (explicit)

What this price covers: Level 3 Basic Bundle: the language arts, handwriting and math sets. The math answer key ($11.99), science and history are extra.

Try it free: Full Language Arts courses for K to 8 are free PDF downloads; other subjects are paid

What moms say

Pros

  • Very affordable, and some lower levels are free to download.
  • Open and go with little planning, so busy moms can start right away.
  • Pretty, colorful pages and good books that many kids enjoy.
  • Ties spelling, grammar, reading and writing together in one daily lesson.

Cons

  • Runs harder than the grade on the cover, so many kids need to start a level lower.
  • The math course gets mixed reviews compared to the language arts.
  • Moms tend to love it or drop it; some switch mid-year when it does not fit their child.
  • Some readers and manipulatives are sold separately.

Most independent reviews cover the language arts only; detailed independent reviews of the math and full program were thin in search results.

From independent reviews: Cathy Duffy Reviews: The Good and the Beautiful Language Arts Levels 3 through 5 · Cathy Duffy Reviews: The Good and the Beautiful Language Arts Levels 6 and 7 · Joy in the Ordinary: TGTB Language Arts Wasn't a Good Fit, Now What?

The Mystery of History (Bright Ideas Press)

Bright Ideas Press

Eden earns a commission

Grades 1-12 · History / social studies, Bible, Geography · Eclectic / mixed · About $100 (per family set (one-time)) · Christian (explicit)

What this price covers: Volume I in print: the Student Reader plus the Companion Guide, a one-time purchase.

Try it free: Free PDF sample of Volume I with sample lessons, hosted by the publisher. The product page itself shows no sample tab right now.

What moms say

Pros

  • Families like that Bible history and world history are woven together in order.
  • Easy to use with several ages, with activity choices for younger and older kids.
  • Beautifully produced books that read aloud well.
  • Older students get research projects that reach parts of history often skipped.

Cons

  • Many moms find each lesson short and light, so older kids need extra books.
  • The writing feels folksy to some, and some parents felt it added details to stories.
  • Volume 2 is a big jump in difficulty from Volume 1.
  • U.S. history coverage is thin in the later volumes.

From independent reviews: Cathy Duffy Reviews: The Mystery of History · Well-Trained Mind forum: Mystery of History, love it or hate it? · Well-Trained Mind forum: Do you find Mystery of History to be enough history?

Grades K-3 · Reading / phonics · Classical · About $67 (per family set (one-time)) · Secular / neutral

What this price covers: Revised Edition set: Instructor Book plus Student Book, a one-time purchase. Price from a retailer.

Try it free: Free sample under the book picture on the product page, including the table of contents.

What moms say

Pros

  • Fully scripted lessons mean almost no prep for the parent.
  • It is thorough, systematic phonics that carries a child through about fourth grade.
  • It is very affordable for how much it covers.

Cons

  • It is plain and text heavy, with few pictures, so some kids find it dry.
  • The script can feel stiff and repetitive.
  • It does not teach writing or spelling, so you need other materials.
  • Many families add games or readers to keep kids engaged.

From independent reviews: Cathy Duffy Reviews: The Ordinary Parent's Guide to Teaching Reading · The Curriculum Choice: The Ordinary Parent's Guide to Teaching Reading · Well-Trained Mind forum: Honest thoughts on OPGTR

The Peaceful Press

The Peaceful Press

Grades K-6 · Bible, History / social studies, Geography, Language arts, Science, Art · Literature-based · About $59 (per family set (one-time)) · Christian (explicit)

What this price covers: The Nourishing Nature Kindergarten guide. The K guides have no religious instruction (Bible verse cards are offered); the elementary units include direct Bible lessons.

Try it free: Free resources collection with sample weeks and printables.

What moms say

Pros

  • Moms praise the gentle, relational rhythm and the beautiful book choices.
  • Kids love the projects and family recipes built into each unit.
  • Grades 1 to 6 can share one course, which makes teaching several kids easier.
  • The guides are affordable and very thorough, with weekly plans laid out.

Cons

  • Everything is digital, so there is a lot to print.
  • You must buy or borrow many library books every week.
  • Math is not included past preschool, and grammar, spelling and phonics need extra programs.
  • It is lighter on science and rigor than many programs, and some units cover heavy topics too early for young kids.

Most mom blog reviews are enthusiastic; the cons come mainly from Cathy Duffy's review. Forum discussion was thin.

From independent reviews: Cathy Duffy Reviews: The Peaceful Press Themed Unit Curriculum · Renee Emerson: Review of the Playful Pioneers homeschool curriculum · Treehouse Schoolhouse: Curriculum Review, The Peaceful Preschool

The Story of the World

Well-Trained Mind Press

Eden earns a commission

Grades 1-8 · History / social studies, Geography · Classical · About $71 (per subject per year) · Secular / neutral

What this price covers: Volume 1 (Ancient Times, grades 1 to 4): text $21.95, instructor guide $30.95 and student workbook $17.95, for a full year. An extra child adds a $17.95 workbook.

Try it free: Free sampler with sample chapters, activity book and test pages

What moms say

Pros

  • Kids love the storytelling. It reads like a story, not a textbook.
  • The audiobooks are a favorite for car school and for read-aloud time.
  • The activity book adds maps, coloring pages, projects and book lists, so it works for several ages at once.
  • It covers cultures well beyond Europe, such as China, India and Africa.

Cons

  • It goes broad rather than deep, so many moms add an illustrated history encyclopedia.
  • The activity book, tests and worksheet packs are separate purchases, and the add-ons get pricey.
  • Some readers have found factual errors, especially in the later volumes.
  • Some volumes feel scattered, and some chapters may need skipping or editing depending on your family's views.

From independent reviews: Cathy Duffy Reviews: The Story of the World, Volumes 1-4 · TheHomeSchoolMom reader reviews: The Story of the World · Hip Homeschool Moms: Story of the World reviews

Grades 7-12 · Logic · Classical · About $108 (per child per year) · Christian (explicit)

What this price covers: Traditional Logic I complete set: student text, workbook, teacher key, quizzes and test, plus streaming videos. Listed $108.30; seen on sale at $81.23.

What moms say

Pros

  • Video lessons and an answer key let a parent with no logic background support the student.
  • Students can work mostly on their own with a clear five-day routine for each chapter.
  • Daily exercises are short, and quizzes and tests are available.
  • It teaches classic formal logic thoroughly, and Book II adds real-life examples.

Cons

  • It is heavy on definitions and advanced vocabulary.
  • Reviewers say it fits high school or very mature junior high students.
  • Moms without a logic background found they could not help much and relied on the videos.
  • Even one adult returning to school called the first book really advanced.

Cathy Duffy's review was last edited in 2016, and both blog posts appear to be Review Crew posts.

From independent reviews: Cathy Duffy Reviews: Traditional Logic · Big Family Blessings: Traditional Logic, Memoria Press review · Troutwife: Traditional Logic I and II review

Trail Guide to Learning (Geography Matters)

Geography Matters, Inc. (GeoMatters)

Eden earns a commission

Grades 3-8 · Language arts, Reading / phonics, Writing, Science, History / social studies, Geography, Art, Music · Unit study · About $447 (per family per year) · Christian-friendly

What this price covers: Paths of Exploration Complete Package for one year, grades 3 to 5: teacher guides, required resources and digital student pages. Every subject but math.

Try it free: Samples tab on each package page with a series brochure and sample lessons. Page was rate-limited when checked, so seen in search results only.

What moms say

Pros

  • Lessons are laid out day by day with parent notes in the margins, so it is easy to follow.
  • History, geography, science, art and language arts all hang on one theme, so kids study fewer topics in more depth.
  • Grade icons and extension activities let siblings of different ages share the same course.
  • Real books and biographies carry the lessons, which many families enjoy.

Cons

  • It depends on a long list of required books that cost extra and are not always at the library.
  • Parents report it takes an hour or two a day of hands-on teaching, with dictation and narration that need you there.
  • There is a lot of printing and gathering before you start.
  • Math is not included, and the Bible portion is sold separately.

Forum threads were seen in search results but could not be opened (site blocked automated reading); forum themes come from search summaries.

From independent reviews: Cathy Duffy Reviews: Trail Guide to Learning · Well-Trained Mind: Thinking about buying Paths of Exploration, comments? · Well-Trained Mind: Trail Guide to Learning series for learning challenged?

TruthQuest History

TruthQuest History

Grades 1-12 · History / social studies, Writing, Bible · Literature-based · About $30 (per family set (one-time)) · Christian (explicit)

What this price covers: One guide covering one era (for example Ancient Greece). Living books are bought separately.

What moms say

Pros

  • Huge book lists by topic and reading level, great for families who love real books.
  • Helps kids connect ideas, art and faith across time, not just dates.
  • Very inexpensive compared with most history programs.
  • Very flexible: use any spine and move at your own pace.

Cons

  • No daily or weekly schedule, so mom does all the planning.
  • Many suggested books are old or out of print, and some libraries have few of them.
  • The author's chatty commentary woven throughout is too much for some families.
  • No tests or review built in, and coverage leans heavily Western.

From independent reviews: Cathy Duffy Reviews: TruthQuest History · Well-Trained Mind forum: TruthQuest history, do you like it? · Well-Trained Mind forum: For those who have used TruthQuest History

Understanding the Times (Summit Ministries)

Summit Ministries

Eden earns a commission

Grades 9-12 · Bible, Logic, History / social studies · Traditional / textbook · About $117 (per child per year) · Christian (explicit)

What this price covers: 1 teacher and 1 student digital license for 350 days. No printed books.

Screen-based

Try it free: Free sample lesson PDFs for Foundations, Worldviews, Apologetics and Culture, plus a series sampler. No form needed.

What moms say

Pros

  • Thorough and well organized, with a glossary, index and notes that help teens follow along.
  • Prepares older teens to understand and discuss other worldviews before college.
  • Video course format brings in many speakers, and it can be done in one or two semesters.

Cons

  • The reading is dense and best for strong, older readers (grades 10 to 12).
  • It is a big time commitment for a single course.
  • Older editions had DVD and computer format problems; check which version you are buying.
  • Families should know it carries a conservative political slant as well as a Christian one.

Thin evidence on day-to-day workload; the online course review page would not load and forum threads were blocked, so the time-commitment point is inferred from book length.

From independent reviews: Cathy Duffy Reviews: Understanding the Times, A Survey of Competing Worldviews · Cathy Duffy Reviews: Understanding the Times online course · Well-Trained Mind: Worldview curriculum, Truth Project, Summit, other?

Veritas Press

Veritas Press (Lancaster, PA)

Eden earns a commission

Grades K-12 · Bible, Language arts, Reading / phonics, Writing, Math, Science, History / social studies, Foreign language, Logic · Classical · Prep: Open-and-go · About $249 (per subject per year) · Christian (explicit)

What this price covers: One self-paced history course (for example Old Testament and Ancient Egypt, grades 2 to 6). Self-paced Bible is $199; Omnibus is $349.

Screen-based

Try it free: 52 free sample lessons from the self-paced History, Bible and Omnibus courses. No signup needed.

What moms say

Pros

  • Kids find the self-paced history videos and review games fun and memorable.
  • The course does most of the teaching and grading, so it saves mom a lot of time.
  • Progress and scores are tracked for you, which makes record keeping easy.
  • Families can work at their own pace on their own schedule.

Cons

  • Cost is the most common complaint, especially with several children enrolled.
  • Flashcards and reading books are extra purchases on top of enrollment.
  • It is a lot of screen time compared with book-based history.
  • Younger kids may need a parent to read questions aloud, and quizzes do not allow corrections.

Feedback found is mostly about the self-paced history courses; little independent feedback surfaced on the live Veritas Scholars Academy classes.

From independent reviews: Cathy Duffy Reviews: Veritas Press History · Well-Trained Mind forum: Anyone use Veritas Press self paced history courses? · Hip Homeschool Moms: Veritas Press History review

Grades K-12 · Bible, Language arts, Writing, Math, Science, History / social studies, Foreign language, Logic · Classical · About $749 (per subject per year) · Christian (explicit)

What this price covers: One full-year live online course for a part-time student; live classes start in 2nd grade. A typical full-time Grammar School year is about $2,866.

Screen-based

Wilson Hill Academy

Wilson Hill Academy

Grades K-12 · Language arts, Reading / phonics, Writing, Math, Science, History / social studies, Geography, Foreign language, Logic · Classical · Christian (explicit)

Screen-based

Try it free: Wilson Hill's own course store has free mini-courses (for example a science and a literature mini-course) so kids can try a class style. No free trial of live classes found.

What moms say

Pros

  • Parents praise many of the teachers, especially in math.
  • Live classes twice a week give clear expectations and a steady workload.
  • Classes are rigorous and prepare students well for college-level work.
  • Families can take just a few classes rather than enrolling full time.

Cons

  • Tuition is high and has gone up, with extra fees on top.
  • The workload and pace are heavy, so two or three classes a year is plenty for most kids.
  • Quality depends a lot on the teacher, and some courses felt less rigorous than expected.
  • Fixed live class times can crowd the family schedule.

Evidence comes almost entirely from Well-Trained Mind forum threads, several years old; no Cathy Duffy full review was found.

From independent reviews: Well-Trained Mind forum: Wilson Hill Academy · Well-Trained Mind forum: Wilson Hill Academy for average student and diploma? · Well-Trained Mind forum: Feedback on composition classes at Wilson Hill

Grades 4-12 · Writing · Traditional / textbook · Prep: Open-and-go · About $31 (per subject per year) · Christian-friendly

What this price covers: Wordsmith (3rd edition): student book $21.00 plus teacher's guide $10.00. Prices not confirmed on the product page.

What moms say

Pros

  • Moms say the casual, funny tone helps even reluctant writers stop dreading writing time.
  • Lessons are short and build step by step, with little busy work.
  • Clear lessons let older kids work fairly independently while a parent reviews their writing.
  • One book covers each level, and free lesson plans are on the publisher's site, so it stays affordable.

Cons

  • It is a writing program only, not a full language arts curriculum.
  • Kids need basic grammar first, or you will need extra grammar material alongside it.
  • Most students need more than a year per book, and the middle book skips reports and research papers.
  • Some assignments call for a newspaper or a separate notebook, and answers are given only for some exercises.

Both blog posts were written with review copies (Monkey and Mom was sponsored), and The Curriculum Choice post dates to about 2011.

From independent reviews: Cathy Duffy Reviews: Wordsmith series · Monkey and Mom: Wordsmith Apprentice review · The Curriculum Choice: Wordsmith

Writing & Rhetoric (Classical Academic Press)

Classical Academic Press

Eden earns a commission

Grades 3-9 · Writing · Classical · About $24 (per subject per year) · Christian-friendly

What this price covers: Book 1 student edition, one semester. A full year takes two books.

Try it free: Free guided page tour of Book 1: Fable on the publisher's tour site.

What moms say

Pros

  • Fables, myths and stories keep kids interested, even reluctant writers.
  • It builds writing step by step through retelling and imitating good models.
  • The books are attractive and clearly laid out.
  • Moms who stay with it report big growth in how their kids think and write.

Cons

  • It gives little direct teaching, so the parent has to explain and guide a lot.
  • Lessons can be long, and the later books get demanding.
  • Kids who need very concrete directions often struggle and families switch programs.
  • You still need a separate grammar program.

From independent reviews: Well-Trained Mind forum: Pros/Cons Classical Academic Press Writing & Rhetoric · Well-Trained Mind forum: Anyone else really like Writing and Rhetoric? · Cathy Duffy Reviews: Writing & Rhetoric Series

Zearn Math

Zearn (501(c)(3) nonprofit)

Grades K-8 · Math · Online / video · About $0 (free) · Secular / neutral

What this price covers: A free family account with K to 8 digital math lessons.

Screen-based

What moms say

Pros

  • It is free for families, with a full set of digital lessons for each grade.
  • Every lesson follows the same predictable routine, which can ease resistance and build confidence.
  • Visual models help kids understand why the math works, not just the steps.
  • It is open-and-go and flags when a child needs extra review.

Cons

  • Quick or advanced learners may find the pace slow and repetitive.
  • Many students in online reviews call it boring and say one wrong answer can restart a whole section.
  • Some kids drift during the video lessons unless an adult sits nearby.
  • It is all on screen, so kids may need extra paper practice, and some report glitches marking right answers wrong.

Thin: the Modulo review is based on materials and parent feedback, not personal use, and Trustpilot reviews are mostly from students using it at school.

From independent reviews: Modulo: Zearn, an in-depth review for homeschooling math · Trustpilot: Zearn reviews

Zeezok Music Appreciation

Zeezok Publishing

Grades K-6 · Music, History / social studies, Geography · Literature-based · About $215 (per family set (one-time)) · Christian-friendly

What this price covers: Book 1 Collection with USB, at the publisher's retail price (its page showed $182.99 as 'Your Price'). The publisher says it meets K to 6 music appreciation standards.

Try it free: The Book 1 student activity book page has a Download a sample PDF link.

What moms say

Pros

  • Kids enjoy the composer storybooks, which read like stories rather than textbooks.
  • Lessons are laid out step by step, so a parent with no music background can teach it.
  • Each composer unit mixes in maps, history, cooking and moving to music, so it feels like a mini unit study.
  • The recordings are good quality and fill a full school year with seven composers.

Cons

  • The full set is pricey, and each child needs their own activity book.
  • Lapbook pages must be printed ahead, ideally in color, which adds prep and ink.
  • Cut and paste work can feel babyish to older kids in the range.
  • Younger children need most of it read aloud, so it is not independent work for them.

Little critical feedback exists. Most blog reviews are review-crew posts written after receiving a free copy, so the cons lean on Cathy Duffy's review.

From independent reviews: Cathy Duffy Reviews: Music Appreciation for the Elementary Grades · Music in Our Homeschool: Review of Zeezok Music Appreciation Book 1 · Well-Trained Mind forum: DD6 is obsessed with classical music and composers

Helpful extras

Apps, videos, songs and books that can sit alongside a curriculum. Not a full curriculum on their own.

Bible · Online / video · About $0 (free) · Christian (explicit)

Video library

What this price covers: All videos, podcasts, articles and classes are free. Made for a general audience, not for children.

Screen-based

What moms say

Pros

  • Moms say the drawings and friendly narration help the Bible come alive and make hard passages easier to follow.
  • The videos give helpful background on each book and show how the whole Bible points to Jesus.
  • They pair well with reading the passage first and then talking it over as a family.
  • Grown-ups say they learn a lot too, so parents can watch and discuss alongside their kids.

Cons

  • One pastor reviewer cautions that the videos leave out or play down God's wrath and Christ's death turning it away.
  • Reviewers urge families to watch with discernment and test the teaching against Scripture.
  • Some videos discuss mature Bible stories in detail, so preview them before showing young children.
  • The polished, easy-to-watch style can lead viewers to accept the teaching without thinking it through.

Sources date from about 2014 to 2021. A Gospel Coalition Australia pastor (2018) urges caution about how the videos handle God's wrath and the atonement.

From independent reviews: Plugged In: Bible Project · The Gospel Coalition Australia: The Bible Project, brilliant but flawed · The Gingham Apron: The Bible Project

Code.org (free)

Code.org (site now brands itself CodeAI), 501(c)(3) nonprofit

Science · Online / video · About $0 (free) · Secular / neutral

Free library

What this price covers: All student courses, tools and activities are free.

Screen-based

What moms say

Pros

  • It is free with no ads, and one site runs from kindergarten into high school courses.
  • Kids build art, stories and games step by step, with cheerful encouragement as they go.
  • Little parent prep is needed, and self-paced units suit kids who like to work alone.
  • Unplugged lessons teach computing ideas away from the screen.

Cons

  • Many lessons assume a classroom, so a parent has to adapt group activities for one child.
  • Younger kids may need help with the reading in some lessons.
  • The sheer number of courses can feel overwhelming at first.
  • Some high school answer keys need a verified teacher account, which not every homeschool parent can get.

No parent forum or blog reviews could be opened; sources are editorial, and Modulo and HomeschoolPicks do not say they used it.

From independent reviews: Common Sense Media: Code.org review · Modulo: Code.org review · HomeschoolPicks: Code.org for Homeschool review

Grades 6-12 · Science · Online / video · About $99 (monthly subscription) · Secular / neutral

Course library

What this price covers: Individual All Access plan for one month; yearly billing is advertised as two months free. The free tier covers only Intro to Programming with Karel.

Screen-based

What moms say

Pros

  • Short videos, readings and hands-on exercises let teens write real code at their own pace.
  • Automatic grading gives instant feedback, which helps parents who cannot check code themselves.
  • Parents in reviews describe it as well organized and easy to use.
  • Early projects like simple games and art programs give kids a quick sense of success.

Cons

  • Some parents found the exercises dull and repetitive, and the site a bit glitchy.
  • Parents say help is hard to get when a child is stuck.
  • It suits self-motivated teens more than beginners, younger kids or reluctant learners.
  • Some tutorial videos play on YouTube, where unrelated videos with crude content can pop up, so check in.

Thin: parent views come only as Common Sense Media's summary of 11 parent reviews, and the HomeschoolPicks page has affiliate links and no named author.

From independent reviews: Common Sense Media: Parents' Guide to CodeHS · Common Sense Media: Parent reviews of CodeHS · HomeschoolPicks: Best Computer Science Curriculum for Homeschool

DragonBox (math apps)

Kahoot DragonBox AS ("A Kahoot company")

Grades K-8 · Math, Reading / phonics, Logic · Online / video · About $36 (per family per year) · Secular / neutral

App

What this price covers: Kahoot!+ Bronze plan for one year, which unlocks the DragonBox math apps and the Poio reading app. Monthly it is $9.

Screen-based

What moms say

Pros

  • Kids learn to balance and solve simple equations through puzzles, often without realizing it is algebra.
  • It starts with pictures instead of numbers, so young kids can begin with no algebra background.
  • One mom says her daughter found it relaxing, since mistakes can be undone without the stress of grades.
  • Lovely graphics and a playful feel can help kids feel good about math.

Cons

  • Skills from the game do not carry over to paper algebra on their own, so plan written practice too.
  • Extra moves cost points, and a stray tap can count as a mistake, which frustrates some kids.
  • Young children need an adult to read the instructions.
  • It covers only basic equations, and moving on to real algebra takes strong arithmetic skills.

Reviews cover the algebra apps only. Two of three sources are from 2015 and 2016, and the Unschool Rules post was compensated.

From independent reviews: Common Sense Media: Kahoot! Algebra by DragonBox · Unschool Rules: DragonBox algebra app · EdSurge: Enter the DragonBox, can a game really teach third graders algebra?

Drive Thru History

Drive Thru History (produced by ColdWater Media, Inc.); courses at Drive Thru History Adventures

History / social studies, Bible · Online / video · About $90 (per family set (one-time)) · Christian (explicit)

Video library

What this price covers: One Adventures course (for example The Gospels) with lifetime streaming and its curriculum included.

Screen-based

What moms say

Pros

  • Kids find the host funny, and filming on location brings history and Bible places to life.
  • Episodes run about 30 minutes and pack in a lot without dragging.
  • The online course adds discussion questions, art, readings and answer guides for deeper study.
  • The whole family can watch together, with younger kids answering questions out loud.

Cons

  • Some reenactments, like the crucifixion, and some ancient history details may be too intense for little ones.
  • The older ancient and American history footage looks dated on a modern TV.
  • High schoolers may need added material to count it as a half credit course.
  • The written course is aimed at ages 12 and up, so younger children need help with the work.

Both blog reviews are 2018 Review Crew posts with free access and affiliate links.

From independent reviews: Plugged In: Drive Thru History with Dave Stotts · Day By Day in Our World: Ancient history with Drive Thru History Adventures · Training Happy Hearts: Drive Thru History Adventures review

Heritage History

Heritage History

Grades 6-12 · History / social studies · Literature-based · About $0 (free) · Secular / neutral

Free library

What this price covers: All books and study programs are free (PDF and EPUB).

Screen-based

What moms say

Pros

  • Moms like reading real narrative histories instead of a textbook, and some value the older perspective.
  • The books are digital and move easily to a Kindle, iPad or computer, saving shelf space.
  • Maps, timelines, study aids and a reading log help a parent keep track.
  • Kids can pick topics and explore history on their own.

Cons

  • The books start around a fourth grade reading level, so younger kids need them read aloud.
  • The old writing style and long passages can be hard for struggling readers.
  • Some words and ideas need explaining before reading.
  • It is not a fit for families who want textbooks, vocabulary lists and tests.

All three are older free-copy posts (around 2012) about the earlier CD version; Cathy Duffy's review page returned an error twice.

From independent reviews: This Reading Mama: Heritage History review · Ben and Me: Heritage History review · Special Connection Homeschool: Heritage History review

Grades 9-12 · History / social studies, Language arts, Bible, Art, Math, Science · Online / video · About $0 (free) · Christian (explicit)

Free library

What this price covers: All online courses are free with an account (email required). Self-paced and not for credit.

Screen-based

What moms say

Pros

  • The courses are free, with expert lectures, question and answer videos, and linked readings.
  • Teens can work through them on their own with little parent teaching.
  • Readings include primary sources like the Declaration and the Federalist Papers, which spark good discussion.
  • Families can watch just the videos or build a fuller semester course around them.

Cons

  • Hillsdale does not track progress or award credit, so parents decide how to count it.
  • They are lighter than on-campus courses and serve better as supplements than full programs.
  • Quizzes test the lectures, so a student can pass without reading the books.
  • The viewpoint is openly conservative, which some families may find one-sided on certain topics.

All three reviews are from Cathy Duffy Reviews, and the overview review dates to 2017; no parent forum or blog reviews could be opened.

From independent reviews: Cathy Duffy Reviews: Hillsdale On-line Courses · Cathy Duffy Reviews: Constitution 101 · Cathy Duffy Reviews: Great Books 101: Ancient to Medieval Literature

Homeschool Connections

Homeschool Connections

Grades 3-12 · Bible, Language arts, Writing, Math, Science, History / social studies, Art, Music, Foreign language, Logic, Life skills · Online / video · About $430 (per family per year) · Christian (explicit)

Course library

What this price covers: Unlimited Access for one year: 500+ recorded courses. Monthly it is $39.97; one course alone is $21.97 a month.

Screen-based

Hooked on Phonics

Hooked & Company, Inc. DBA Hooked on Phonics

Grades K-2 · Reading / phonics, Language arts, Math · Online / video · About $24 (monthly subscription) · Secular / neutral

App

What this price covers: Complete Phonics for one month, up to 3 learners. With practice books it is $29.94 a month; no yearly plan is listed.

Screen-based

What moms say

Pros

  • Lessons follow a clear, logical path from letters to sight words to simple books.
  • Reviewers say songs, short videos and games keep young kids engaged without overwhelming them.
  • It is open and go, and kids move up by skill rather than by grade.
  • Parents get progress updates, and one reviewer found the workbooks well designed.

Cons

  • Activities repeat a lot, and slow responses after a wrong answer can confuse kids.
  • One mom found the app glitchy and customer service hard to reach.
  • It focuses on decoding, so you will likely add real storybooks for fluency and comprehension.
  • One homeschool mom said it suits mild reading struggles but not a child with severe dyslexia.

Both parent write-ups used free or company-supplied materials, and the 2018 one covers the older workbook kit rather than the current app.

From independent reviews: Common Sense Media: Hooked on Phonics Learn and Read · Homeschool Giveaways: Hooked on Phonics review · Reviewed: Hooked on Phonics for kids with learning disabilities

Khan Academy Kids

Khan Academy

Grades K-2 · Reading / phonics, Math, Language arts · Online / video · About $0 (free) · Secular / neutral

App

What this price covers: The whole app (activities, videos and books), said to be free with no subscription, ads or in-app purchases. Not confirmed on Khan Academy's own page.

Screen-based

What moms say

Pros

  • It is completely free and covers early reading, math, logic and social and emotional skills.
  • A learning path picks activities based on your child's age and past work.
  • Moms say it is easy to navigate, and the books, videos and games hold little ones' attention.
  • Drawing and recording tools let kids tell their own stories, and parents find it pleasant to listen to.

Cons

  • Content ends around first or second grade, so kids outgrow it fairly quickly.
  • The math is lighter than some expect, so reviewers suggest pairing it with a fuller math program.
  • It is still screen time, and reviewers suggest a parent play alongside rather than hand it off.
  • Some parents report glitches, and setup needs an email check and microphone access for some activities.

The Cool Mom Tech review is from 2018; no long-term homeschool family review found.

From independent reviews: Common Sense Media: Khan Academy Kids · Cool Mom Tech: The new Khan Academy Kids app · Modulo: Khan Academy Kids review

Learning Ally (audiobooks)

Learning Ally (501(c)(3) nonprofit)

Grades K-12 · Reading / phonics, Language arts · Literature-based · About $135 (per family per year) · Secular / neutral

Other

What this price covers: Family membership for one year (annual only); the page does not say how many children it covers. Use requires a demonstrated learning disability, visual impairment or physical disability.

Screen-based

What moms say

Pros

  • Most books are read by real human narrators, which models smooth, expressive reading.
  • Text is highlighted as it is read, and kids can change text size, colors and reading speed.
  • The library includes textbooks, which one mom says has helped her older kids keep up.
  • A homeschool mom of kids with dyslexia calls it a strong choice and more affordable than Audible.

Cons

  • You must show proof of a reading-related disability, such as an IEP, 504 plan or signed form, to join.
  • Some books use a computer voice, and one mom notes Audible's recordings are more professional.
  • The library spans all grades and includes mature titles, so younger kids need help choosing books.
  • Assigning and downloading books through a web browser can feel tricky at first.

Thin: two sources; the Common Sense page was last updated in 2021 and the blog post dates from 2015 with replies into 2024. Well-Trained Mind threads were found but the forum blocked opening.

From independent reviews: Common Sense Media: Learning Ally Audiobooks · Homeschooling with Dyslexia: audio book sources post

Lexercise

Lexercise

Grades K-11 · Reading / phonics, Writing, Language arts · Online / video · About $150 (monthly subscription) · Secular / neutral

Other

What this price covers: Basic Therapy, parent-led, for one month. The page shows a promotion: $90 a month instead of $150.

Screen-based

What moms say

Pros

  • Moms say working online with a trained dyslexia clinician saves the driving and waiting of in-person tutoring.
  • Parents get training videos and weekly check-ins, so they know exactly what to practice at home.
  • Short daily games reinforce each week's lesson, and kids generally enjoy them.
  • Both reviewing moms saw clear gains in their sons' reading, spelling and confidence.

Cons

  • It is a real expense, and moms admit it can feel steep for a single-income family.
  • It takes steady commitment, with a weekly session plus practice games most days.
  • The parent stays closely involved, so it is not hands-off for mom.
  • One son still needed more work afterward to reach grade level, so therapy alone may not finish the job.

Thin: both reviews were written by moms who got discounted service from Lexercise, one from about 2013; no unpaid reviews or forum threads found.

From independent reviews: Weird Unsocialized Homeschoolers: Lexercise online dyslexia treatment gets results · Hip Homeschool Moms: Dyslexia test, does Lexercise work

Language arts, Reading / phonics, History / social studies · Literature-based · About $0 (free) · Secular / neutral

Free library

What this price covers: The whole catalog of public-domain audiobooks, read by volunteers, is free.

What moms say

Pros

  • It is completely free, with classics and older children's books to stream or download for offline listening.
  • Moms say many recordings are surprisingly good, and some sound close to a professional audiobook.
  • Kids can enjoy books above their reading level, and listening together sparks family conversation.
  • If you dislike a reader, there is often another recording of the same book, and listener reviews help you choose.

Cons

  • Readers are unscreened volunteers, so quality varies from book to book and even chapter to chapter.
  • Some books use a different reader for each chapter.
  • Only older public domain books are offered, so newer titles are not available.
  • Some old books carry outdated or offensive ideas, so preview titles before young kids listen.

From independent reviews: TheHomeSchoolMom: Listen to free audio books with LibriVox · The Book Designer: Audiobooks on LibriVox, are they any good? · Exodus Books: LibriVox

Bible · Literature-based · Christian (explicit)

Devotional

What moms say

Pros

  • Each week shows how an Old Testament passage points forward to Jesus.
  • Ten-minute readings fit busy days, and one dad says his daughter asked for it every night.
  • The conversational tone reads aloud easily, and simple hands-on activities stay on the main point.
  • Only verse references are printed, so families can read from their own Bible translation.

Cons

  • Discussion times can run long, so one reviewer suggests using a timer.
  • Some activities need supplies, so parents should read ahead.
  • Prayers are suggested rather than written out, so parents lead them in their own words.
  • It covers the Old Testament only, so the New Testament needs the second volume.

Few independent reviews; two are short posts from 2011 and 2012, and no homeschool forum threads could be opened.

From independent reviews: Ministry to Children: Long Story Short review · Terry Virgo: Long Story Short review · Aaron Armstrong: Book review, Long Story Short

Mango Languages

Mango Languages

Foreign language · Online / video · About $150 (per family per year) · Secular / neutral

App

What this price covers: Family plan billed yearly ($12.50 a month); month to month it is $19.99. Many public libraries give free access.

Screen-based

What moms say

Pros

  • Kids start using real phrases from the first lesson, since it is built around everyday conversations.
  • Moms say a parent does not need to know the language, because the program leads each lesson.
  • Short grammar and culture notes are built in, and a voice tool lets kids compare their pronunciation.
  • Many families can use it free with a library card, and parents can check progress anytime.

Cons

  • There is little writing practice, so families add a workbook or other writing work.
  • Grammar is light, so kids who need deeper grammar will want another resource alongside it.
  • It suits kids who can read along with the narrator, and Common Sense rates it for nine and up.
  • Without free library access, reviewers say a subscription can get expensive.

Sources date from 2009 to 2021, and the Our Journey Westward review was written with a free subscription and payment.

From independent reviews: Common Sense Media: Mango Languages · Our Journey Westward: Homeschool with Mango Languages · The Curriculum Choice: Mango Languages, an online foreign language course

NASA STEM Engagement (student/educator resources)

NASA (National Aeronautics and Space Administration)

Grades K-12 · Science, Math · Eclectic / mixed · Secular / neutral

Free library

What moms say

Pros

  • It is free and spans kindergarten through high school, with videos, hands-on projects and games.
  • Lessons tie science and math to real NASA missions and were written by subject experts.
  • One educator reviewer found the site well organized and easy to get around.

Cons

  • Some materials assume background knowledge, so younger kids will likely need a parent to guide them.
  • The sheer amount of content can feel overwhelming when you first visit.

Thin: only one openable review, a 2025 educator peer review on MERLOT; no mom reviews found.

From independent reviews: MERLOT peer review: Explore NASA STEM

Nessy Reading & Spelling

Nessy Learning Ltd.

Grades 1-5 · Reading / phonics, Language arts · Online / video · About $16 (monthly subscription) · Secular / neutral

App

What this price covers: Home subscription, starting price per month. The page shows no yearly price.

Screen-based

What moms say

Pros

  • Moms say the games make lots of phonics practice feel like play, so kids work hard without noticing.
  • It teaches one sound pattern at a time, in order, with plenty of review for kids with dyslexia.
  • Free printable worksheets match each lesson and give extra practice away from the screen.
  • A placement check and settings let a child skip skills already mastered.

Cons

  • Moms say it is better as reinforcement than as the only reading program for a child with dyslexia.
  • Kids can move too fast and forget concepts, so a parent still needs to check in and review.
  • There is a lot to navigate at first, and some families may not like the island theme's talking idols and haunted huts.
  • Independent research on it is limited, and it does not check whether a child can read real text aloud.

Both mom reviews are from 2017 and were written with a free subscription and payment; the third source is an education site article.

From independent reviews: Homeschooling with Dyslexia: Nessy Reading and Spelling Review · The Unlikely Homeschool: Nessy Reading · Structural Learning: Nessy for Dyslexia

PBS LearningMedia

PBS (with local member stations; the URL redirects to a state station subdomain, e.g. tn.pbslearningmedia.org)

Grades K-12 · Science, Math, Language arts, History / social studies, Art, Health / PE · Online / video · About $0 (free) · Secular / neutral

Video library

What this price covers: Free access to the full library of classroom resources, PreK to 12.

Screen-based

What moms say

Pros

  • It is free, with a huge library of videos and lessons from PBS programs for preschool through high school.
  • Videos and interactive activities are well made and come with background and teaching materials.
  • You can filter by subject and grade, and save favorites into playlists by unit or child.
  • Lesson plans include discussion questions and vocabulary that adapt well to teaching at home.

Cons

  • It is a supplement, not a full curriculum, and has no set order from one lesson to the next.
  • Coverage is uneven, and math is thinner for middle and high school.
  • Lessons are written for classrooms, so parents may need to adapt them and preview some clips.
  • You need a free account to save resources, and most videos need an internet connection.

No mom reviews found; based on an unsigned 2026 homeschool guide and a 2015 educator peer review.

From independent reviews: Homeschool Picks: PBS LearningMedia for Homeschool · MERLOT peer review: PBS LearningMedia

Prodigy Math

Prodigy Education

Grades 1-8 · Math · Online / video · About $0 (free) · Secular / neutral

App

What this price covers: All the math and English game content is free. Optional parent memberships run $9.95 to $19.95 a month for progress tracking and extras.

Screen-based

What moms say

Pros

  • Reviewers say kids who resist math will often play it willingly because it feels like a video game.
  • The free version includes the math content, and questions adjust to your child's level.
  • A free parent dashboard lets you assign skills and see your child's progress.
  • It offers practice from first through eighth grade on computers, tablets and phones.

Cons

  • Parents say the game keeps pushing kids to ask for a paid membership, with frequent ads for it.
  • Battles, pets and shopping can crowd out the math, with long gaps between questions.
  • It is drill practice with little teaching, so it needs a main math program alongside it.
  • Some kids speed-click or pick easy skills to move ahead faster.

No personal mom blog found. Homeschool Fox earns affiliate commission, and Fairplay is a children's advocacy group that strongly criticizes the game's ads.

From independent reviews: Common Sense Media: Prodigy Kids Math Game · Homeschool Fox: Prodigy Math review · Fairplay: Prodigy

Reading Eggs

Blake eLearning (footer links to 3P Learning)

Grades K-7 · Reading / phonics, Language arts, Math · Online / video · About $100 (per family per year) · Secular / neutral

App

What this price covers: Reading and math yearly plan for up to 4 children, including Mathseeds, at regular price (it was on sale for $74.99). Homeschool Max is $299.00 a year.

Screen-based

What moms say

Pros

  • Moms say kids enjoy the games, songs and stories; one child still liked it after a year and a half.
  • A placement test starts each child at their own reading level.
  • Children can work through the lessons on their own, at their own pace.
  • Lessons are short, and every early level includes practice blending sounds into words.

Cons

  • Some moms find it repetitive, and one said the iPad version glitched and crashed.
  • A phonics specialist and UK parents say it teaches some spelling patterns early and lets kids pass items by guessing.
  • Young children may need an adult nearby, since some early games are hard to work with a mouse.
  • One mom said it did not fit her mildly dyslexic child or her gifted child.

Most parent reviews date from 2012 to 2018; the critical post is by a phonics specialist who sells her own materials.

From independent reviews: TheHomeSchoolMom: Reading Eggs parent reviews · Spelfabet: Is Reading Eggs all it's cracked up to be? · Mumsnet: Reading Eggs, any good?

Rosetta Stone Homeschool

Rosetta Stone

Grades 2-12 · Foreign language · Online / video · About $399 (per child per year) · Secular / neutral

App

What this price covers: One user's license; price from a retailer. Retailers disagree on whether it covers every language or just one.

Screen-based

What moms say

Pros

  • Moms say kids can work through it on their own, even when the parent does not speak the language.
  • Picture-based lessons taught fully in the new language feel natural, with native speaker audio.
  • Speaking and listening start in the first lesson, with recording and playback to compare sounds.
  • Short daily sessions of about 10 to 20 minutes fit easily into a homeschool day.

Cons

  • Cost was the most common complaint, and one mom found it a fair deal only on a holiday sale.
  • Speech recognition often failed to pick up children's voices or accents.
  • Grammar is light, so many families add a separate grammar resource.
  • Some kids lost interest as it got harder, and a few said it felt like guessing.

Most parent reviews date from 2010 to 2015; the one recent blog review uses affiliate links.

From independent reviews: TheHomeSchoolMom: Rosetta Stone parent reviews · Monkey and Mom: Rosetta Stone review, German for homeschool

SchoolhouseTeachers.com

The Old Schoolhouse (SchoolhouseTeachers.com)

Grades K-12 · Bible, Language arts, Reading / phonics, Writing, Math, Science, History / social studies, Geography, Art, Music, Health / PE, Foreign language, Life skills · Eclectic / mixed · About $389 (per family per year) · Christian (explicit)

Course library

What this price covers: Family membership for one year, including RightNow Media and World Book Online. Also $129.00 a quarter or $1,850.00 for lifetime.

Screen-based

Seeds Family Worship

Seeds Kids Worship (nonprofit, Nashville TN)

Bible, Music · Eclectic / mixed · About $15 (per family set (one-time)) · Christian (explicit)

Songs

What this price covers: One Scripture song video with hand motions. These are songs and videos, not a curriculum; a 10-CD player bundle is $140.

What moms say

Pros

  • The songs are Bible verses set to music, so kids memorize Scripture just by singing along.
  • Moms say the music is good enough that parents enjoy it too, even without the kids.
  • Styles vary from country to soft rock, and the verse reference is sung so kids remember where it is.
  • The albums reviewed came with a second copy to give to another family.

Cons

  • One mom first thought the CDs were pricey, though she decided they were worth it.
  • The reviewed albums use NIV wording, which may not match the Bible your family memorizes from.

All three reviews are from about 2011 and fully positive; one used a free copy, and no critical reviews were found.

From independent reviews: The Curriculum Choice: Seeds Family Worship · Ministry to Children: What's the deal with Seeds Family Worship? · Cross Rhythms: Seeds of Courage review

Signing Time (ASL)

Signing Time

Foreign language, Reading / phonics, Science, Music · Online / video · About $130 (per family per year) · Secular / neutral

Video library

What this price covers: My Signing Time membership for one year. Monthly it is $12.99.

Screen-based

What moms say

Pros

  • Catchy songs and bright visuals make the signs easy to remember and practice.
  • Moms say their babies and toddlers began signing to communicate before they could talk.
  • Real kids of different ages, including children with disabilities, sign on screen, which takes the pressure off.
  • Short, themed episodes let kids pick favorites, and later series practice earlier signs at a harder level.

Cons

  • Building a full DVD collection adds up, and one mom bought most of hers during sales.
  • It is a video series, so families who limit screens will want to practice signs together away from the TV.
  • One reviewer felt its appeal may be narrower for families without a deaf child or interest in baby signing.

Family posts are old (2010, and 2015 with free videos), and reviewers named few drawbacks, so only three cons are given.

From independent reviews: Common Sense Media: Signing Time · The Curriculum Choice: Signing Time · Homeschool On: My top pick for sign language for kids

Starfall

Starfall Education Foundation (501(c)(3) nonprofit)

Grades K-5 · Reading / phonics, Math, Art, Music · Online / video · About $35 (per family per year) · Secular / neutral

App

What this price covers: Home membership for one year: website and app, 700+ activities. The four-step Learn-to-Read program is free without it.

Screen-based

What moms say

Pros

  • Moms say kids love the catchy songs and stories, and it makes early phonics fun.
  • The core reading lessons are free, and reviewers found no ads on the site.
  • Pre-readers can use it on their own while a parent teaches older siblings.
  • Lessons build step by step, and the storybooks read themselves aloud to the child.

Cons

  • Quick learners can outgrow it fast; one mom said her son finished it in two days.
  • Some moms say kids can click through activities by guessing instead of reading.
  • A few find it dated or repetitive, and one mom was not a fan of the math.
  • There are few checks on what kids learned, and one mom wanted a clearer order to follow.

Only two sources could be opened; many of the parent comments date from 2010 to 2012.

From independent reviews: TheHomeSchoolMom: Starfall parent reviews · Common Sense Media: Starfall

Supercharged Science

Supercharged Science & Math (Supercharged Education)

Grades K-12 · Science, Math · Online / video · About $373 (per family per year) · Secular / neutral

Video library

What this price covers: One year of e-Science, grades K to 8, at a sales-page discount price. Monthly is $47; grades 9 to 12 cost $567 a year.

Screen-based

What moms say

Pros

  • Moms say the hands-on experiments are fun and help kids connect science to everyday life.
  • Most experiments use common household items, and each one has a video and supply list.
  • Lessons are taught by a real scientist, with quizzes and answers included.
  • One mom says her son started building his own inventions within a few weeks.

Cons

  • Several moms say the teacher talks fast and can be hard to follow.
  • It is not open and go; you print pages and gather materials ahead of time.
  • Some materials are hard to find.
  • Some moms found it hard to use, felt it cost too much, and reported slow customer service.

Parent comments span 2010 to 2022; the 2019 blog review used a free subscription, and the forum thread is one parent's post.

From independent reviews: TheHomeSchoolMom: Supercharged Science parent reviews · Farm Fresh Adventures: Supercharged Science review · Confessions of a Homeschooler community: Supercharged Science review

Teach Your Monster to Read

Teach Your Monster Ltd, part of The Usborne Foundation

Grades K-1 · Reading / phonics · Online / video · About $0 (free) · Secular / neutral

App

What this price covers: Free to play on a computer. The mobile apps cost extra; the site does not show the price.

Screen-based

What moms say

Pros

  • Kids design and dress up their own monster, which keeps young learners excited to play.
  • It follows a clear phonics order, from letter sounds to blending, short words and simple sentences.
  • Reviewers found no ads, and the computer version is free to play.
  • Kids can start at one of three levels, and it needs no prep from the parent.

Cons

  • Early levels move slowly and repeat games, so some kids get bored.
  • Getting around the game takes good fine motor skills, which can frustrate little ones.
  • It is a supplement, not a full reading program, and offers limited reading practice.
  • Reviewers suggest a parent play along with children under eight.

No mom blog reviews found; sources are review organizations (one from 2019) and an educator-run homeschool site.

From independent reviews: Common Sense Media: Teach Your Monster to Read · Children and Media Australia: Teach Your Monster to Read · Modulo: Teach Your Monster to Read review

Bible, Music · Classical · Christian (explicit)

Memory book

What moms say

Pros

  • Each book combines Scripture memory, hymns and a catechism in one small volume.
  • Three books are graded by age, so a family can grow with them from toddlers to teens.
  • The question and answer format suits young children, and many verses come in context.
  • Goal pages in the back help track progress, and one dad found the book sturdy and affordable.

Cons

  • The catechisms are Baptist versions, so families from other traditions may want to add their own notes.
  • One reviewer felt the reading plan leans on the New Testament, with Genesis not read until ninth grade.
  • A 2020 reviewer found a few printing errors, such as a wrong verse reference.
  • That reviewer also noted LORD is not set in small caps, so the divine name distinction is lost.

Only two reviews could be found and opened, and one is undated.

From independent reviews: Ministry to Children: Truth and Grace Memory Book review · Things Above: Truth and Grace Memory Book 1 review

Life skills · Online / video · About $0 (free) · Secular / neutral

App

What this price covers: The core typing program is free. An optional Premium Edition exists; the page does not show its price.

Screen-based

What moms say

Pros

  • Moms say it starts at the very beginning with finger placement and builds skills step by step.
  • The free version is truly free, not a short trial, and some families have used it for years.
  • Star ratings, games and instant feedback keep kids motivated, and many happily replay levels.
  • A stats page shows speed, accuracy and progress by key, so parents can see real growth.

Cons

  • The free version shows ads, which some parents and kids find distracting.
  • Kids say it can push speed over accuracy, and some find the scoring rigid or discouraging.
  • Some lessons feel simple and repetitive, and some kids report lag or glitches.
  • You need an account to save progress, and the site keeps prompting you to make one.

The Because We Homeschool post is from 2020 and the Common Sense page was last updated in 2021.

From independent reviews: Common Sense Media: TypingClub · Because We Homeschool: Keyboarding with TypingClub · Everyday Reading: mom blog post on TypingClub

Facts checked November 2026. Prices change, so check the publisher before you buy.

See something out of date? Tell us

How we choose

  • It fits a Christian home. Every pick is openly Christian, or secular and neutral. Nothing here teaches against a Biblical view of where life comes from or what we're made for.
  • It teaches well. It's a real curriculum a mom can teach a subject or a year with, with a track record in independent reviews.
  • Kids enjoy it. We look for games, stories, hands-on work and short lessons.
  • There's room for every kind of kid. We went looking for picks for the music lovers, the artists, the nature kids, the people kids and the big-question kids, not only the readers and the math kids.
  • The facts check out. Prices, grades and prep come from the publisher's own site, or from a named retailer when the publisher doesn't list a price, with the date we checked. If we couldn't confirm something, we say so instead of guessing.
  • Camila approves every pick before it shows up here.

What never decides anything: commissions and sponsors. Nobody can pay to be in this guide or to move up in it.

Questions moms ask

How do I choose a homeschool curriculum?

Start with your child, not the catalog. Before you compare a single curriculum, think about how God made your child, what lights them up, and where they struggle. A curriculum that fits your child gets used; one that doesn't sits on the shelf. Once you know that, narrow it down by grade, subjects, prep time and budget with the filters here, read what other moms say, and try a free sample before you buy.

What does "open-and-go" mean?

Open-and-go curriculum is ready to teach the moment you open it. The lesson, the questions and the activities are on the page, so you don't spend an evening planning. Some curricula ask for light, moderate or heavy prep instead. Filter by prep time to see only the ones that fit your days.

Can I try a homeschool curriculum before I buy it?

Yes. Most of the curricula here link a free sample, trial or free lesson, and some are completely free. Turn on "Has a free sample or trial" to see them.

Can I use ESA funds for these curricula?

Often, yes. Choose your state in the ESA filter and the finder shows the curricula marked ESA-eligible there. Our ESA state guides explain how each program works and how to apply. Rules change, so check your state's program before you buy.

Are these Christian curricula?

Each one was hand-picked: Christian, or secular that doesn't work against your faith. Turn on "Christian curricula only" to see just the Christian ones.

Where do the "what moms say" notes come from?

From independent reviews by homeschool families. Each card links its sources, so you can read the full review yourself.